祸根 第一季 第五集
别忘了 Let's not forget that, uh...
在这次事件中 that in all this...
我失去了我所爱之人 I lost someone I love.
所以你还是坚持自己没有杀她吗 So you still say you didn't kill her?
我这么说 就是因为我没有杀她 Well, I say, I say that because I did not kill her.
你爱这个女人 你了解她 你了解她的生活 You loved this woman. You knew her. You knew her life.
你知道是谁干的吗 Do you have some idea who did?
嗯 我知道 I do. Yeah.
你好吗 亨利 How you doing, Henry?
-挺好 谢谢 先生 -是吗 - Good, thanks, sir. - Yeah?
那晚你为什么在那里 Why were you there that night?
在她公寓外面 Outside her apartment?
因为我当时在散步 Because I was, I was walking.
我一向如此 我不知道走到哪了 Like I always do. I didn't know where I was.
我跟你说过很多次了 I've told you this many times.
真是太巧了 不是吗 It is just such a coincidence, isn't it, that...
我和她有婚外情 你也在场 I was having an affair with her, and, and, you were there.
和我一样 或者曾经一样 我的天哪 Just as I was, or just had been. Oh, my God.
你到底问我什么 What are you asking me?
你在跟踪我吗 Were you following me?
我跟踪你 Was I following you?
是吗 Were you?
你在跟踪我吗 Were you following me?
-你搞笑呢吗 -你在跟踪我吗 格蕾丝 - Are you fucking kidding me? - Were you following me, Grace?
-你敢这么说 -你是乔纳森·弗雷泽吗 - Don't you dare say that-- - Are you Jonathan Fraser?
抱歉 打扰一下 I'm sorry. Excuse me.
-能跟你自拍合影吗 -太疯狂了 - Can we take a selfie with you? - This is wild!
-强尼 这里呢 -不行 - Johnny! Right here! -No. No.
-来张自拍 -不 不 别这样 - Quick selfie. - No. No. Come on.
-简直了 -格蕾丝 格蕾丝 -This is-- - Grace! Grace!
进展如何 How are we doing?
怎么了 What's going on?
我觉得我们都 I think we're both, um...
只是有点预审前紧张而已 A little pre-trial nerves, that's all.
他们证据确凿 毫无疑问 Look, they have a strong case. No question.
但都是间接证据 But it's circumstantial.
没有人目击 Nobody saw anything.
他们没找到凶器 They don't have a murder weapon,
一些科学事实上帮助了我们 and some of the science actually helps us.
他们的情况站不住脚 Their case is vulnerable.
你一直这么说 So you keep saying, um,
尽管你每次说的时候都会有点焦虑 although with a little more anxiety each time you say it.
我的问题是 Here's my question.
我们的情况如何 海莉 What's our case, Haley?
因为我不太清楚 Because I don't really have clarity on that.
我们的辩护要静观其变 Our defense is wait and see.
我告诉过你了 不固定 I told you. It's fluid.
不固定 好的 很好 让我很有信心 谢谢 Fluid. Okay, great. That gives me great confidence. Thank you.
那要看他们怎么对付我们了 It depends on what they throw at us.
好吧 我们来分析一下 Okay. Let's break it down.
我们的情况是你 Our case is you.
你说不是你干的 You say you didn't do it.
解释一下你为什么要跑 Explain why you ran.
我们的情况是你 And our case is you.
你说 相信他所说的 You say, "Believe what he just said."
我无法想象一个忠诚的妻子的话 I can't imagine that the word of a devoted wife
会有多重的份量 would carry much weight.
你忠诚吗 格蕾丝 Are you devoted, Grace?
我人都来了 I'm here.
在这种情况下 我觉得我应该立牌坊了 Under the circumstances, I think I deserve a medal.
陪审团里有七个女人 We have seven women on the jury.
这五位 These five...
都是受过教育的职业人士 are educated, working professionals.
就像你一样 Just like you.
这两位 These two...
被丈夫出轨了 have been cheated on by their husbands.
就像你一样 Just like you.
还有这个人 And then there's this guy.
他比大多数人更清楚 不忠并不意味着谋杀 He knows better than most that infidelity doesn't mean murder.
他自己也有外遇 He's having an affair, himself.
你怎么知道的 How could you possibly know that?
这些人我都了解 I know all these people.
我们利用亚马逊和谷歌的算法 We piggyback on the algorithms of both Amazon and Google.
我知道他们去哪购物 他们去哪里吃饭 I know where they go shopping. Where they go to eat.
他们去哪里度假 我们都知道 Where they go on vacation. We know it all.
我们已经锁定了他们 We're already targeting their Instagram and Facebook accounts
支持辩护的图享和脸书账号 with pro-defense news feeds.
这合法吗 Is that legal?
构不成法律惩罚 It's gray enough to get away with.
我们确实有个小问题 We do have one little problem.
我们所有的对照测试都会出现同样的问题 The same question keeps coming up in all our focus trials.
如果不是你干的 那是谁干的 If you didn't do it, then who did?
我们得提供另一个嫌疑人 We need to offer up another suspect.
那他的不在场证明呢 Well, what about his alibi?
很烦人 我能搞定 Oh, it stinks. I can nick it.
握住他的手 好吗 Take his hand, would you please?
现在就握住 I mean, now.
-为什么 -因为是我要求的 - Why? - Because I said so.
快点 Do it.
感觉他的手 Feel his hand.
感觉她的 Feel hers.
一起感受 Feel together.
如果你俩没感觉 陪审团也不会 If you two don't feel it, neither will the jury.
我没感觉 I'm not feeling that.
这有什么意义 What is the point of this?
重点是你们俩得合二为一 The point is that you two need to be one in the room.
事实是你每天都要出庭作证 In effect, you'll be giving testimony every single day.
庭审的每一分钟 Every single minute of this trial.
陪审员们会研究你们的迹象 The jurors will be studying you for signs.
他有人性吗 Is he human?
她相信他吗 Does she believe him?
她还爱他吗 Does she still love him?
他们会一直评估你们俩 They will constantly be taking measure of you.
分别评估 一起评估 Individually, and jointly.
陪审团不喜欢给帅哥定罪 Look, juries don't like to convict good-looking people.
他们当然不希望让医生坐牢 They certainly don't like to imprison doctors,
他们也不喜欢惩罚有钱人 and they don't like to punish the wealthy.
尽管我们认为自己喜欢和富人过不去 As much as we think we like to stick it to the rich,
到最后 我们并非如此 in the end, we don't.
从来没有 We never do.
陪审员不能带着先入之见 The idea that jurors don't come into this
参与这个案件 with preconceived notions,
这太荒谬了 that's just preposterous.
这个案子已经报道得人尽皆知了 This case has been so well-reported,
我只能说这些陪审员都是骗子 I might go as far as to say that these jurors are liars.
我是说 想加入这个陪审团 I mean, to get on this panel,
他们必须声明 they would have had to have declared
他们对这个案子一无所知 that they know nothing about this case.
是否有人... Does anybody--
简直是娱乐大众 It's just entertainment.
你也得参与其中 Which you need to be a part of.
陪审团会知道你是谁 The jury will know who you are.
海莉说他们什么都会注意到 Haley says that they notice everything.
你的出场 你的反应 Your presence. Your reactions.
-都很重要 -格蕾丝 - It all matters. - Grace.
你这么做是为了你孙子 You're doing this for your grandson.
我会在你身边 I will be at your side,
从今往后都如此 tomorrow and beyond.
但认为这样对亨利最有利的话 But the idea that this best serves Henry
完全是无稽之谈 is absolute nonsense.
不管乔纳森是不是杀人犯 他都必须 Murderer or not, Jonathan must be kept
离你儿子越远越好 as far away from your son as possible.
538今早报道 FiveThirtyEight is reporting
有83%的可能性定罪 an 83% chance of conviction this morning,
相比昨天下降三个点 down three points from just yesterday...
在最后一刻达成认罪协议的计划要么没有实现 Plans for a last-minute plea deal either never materialized,
要么就被否决了 or were squashed.
格蕾丝还好吗 How is Grace doing?
你还跟你女婿说话吗 Are you speaking to your son-in-law?
请把口袋里的金属物品都拿出来 Take all the metal out of your pockets, please.
谢谢 Thank you.
下一位 Next, please.
上前 Step up.
请把口袋里的金属物品都拿出来 Take all the metal out of your pockets, please.
谋杀是肮脏的勾当 Murder is ugly business.
我必须提醒各位 I must warn you,
不管你听说过什么 有何倾向 whatever you've heard, whatever your predispositions,
这次案件 this one,
比你想中更要恶劣 it's worse than you think.
证据会表明 The evidence will show that
乔纳森·弗雷泽和死者有婚外情 Jonathan Fraser was having an affair with the victim.
他于2019年1月8日晚 That he went to the victim's studio
去了死者的工作室 on the night of January 8th, 2019.
他和她发生了性关系 That he sexually penetrated her.
然后他暴力地 That he then violently,
野蛮地 savagely,
将她殴打致死 beat her to death.
然后他逃离了现场 躲了起来 He then fled the scene and went into hiding,
在他被捕之前 before he was captured.
埃琳娜·阿尔维斯被重击 Elena Alves was bludgeoned so badly,
如此恶毒 so viciously,
以至她丈夫都认不出来她了 she was unrecognizable to her own husband.
首先发现死者的是 She was first discovered
她十岁的儿子米格尔 by her 10-year-old son, Miguel.
她被钝器击打了11次 She was hit with a blunt instrument 11 times.
法医发现 The medical examiner found
死者伤口与雕刻锤吻合 that the wounds inflicted were consistent with a sculpting hammer,
雕刻锤属于死者 which belonged to the victim.
这把锤子至今没有找打 A hammer which was never found.
可能是像这样的锤子 It could have been a hammer like this one.
他把她的头骨砸成了浆糊 He turned her skull into mush.
他就一直打 He just kept hitting.
一直打 And hitting.
他就一直打 He just kept hitting.
一直打 And hitting.
比你想象得还要恶劣 It's worse than you think.
如此美丽 充满活力的女人 Such a beautiful, vibrant woman.
当好人遭遇不幸时 When bad things happen to good people,
我们想要答案 我们想要了结 we want answers. We want closure.
我们想要定罪 We want a conviction.
我委托人是唯一人选 My client is the only option.
所以调查才如此局限 That's why the investigation was so limited.
并非因为草率 It wasn't sloppy,
懒惰或疏忽 or lazy, or negligent.
只是特别地 故意缩小了范围 It was specifically and intentionally narrow,
正是因为其他嫌疑犯的证据 precisely because evidence of other suspects
会影响他们快速定罪 would compromise their one shot at a conviction.
我的委托人1月8日和埃琳娜·阿尔维斯做爱了 My client made love to Elena Alves, on January 8th.
他的DNA 现场有精液 His DNA. Semen at the scene.
他为其他被告提供了合理怀疑 He guarantees reasonable doubt to any other defendant,
所以我们甚至不考虑其他可能性了 so we're not even gonna look for other possibilities.
他是我们唯一能抓到的人 He's the only one we can get.
有人用雕刻锤袭击了埃琳娜·阿尔维斯 Somebody else hit Elena Alves with that sculpting hammer,
11次 就像检察官说的 11 times, like the prosecutor said.
人都死了 还继续击打 It continued after she was dead.
那是狂怒 That's rage.
那是仇恨 That's hatred.
求你了 Please.
是满腹仇恨 A lot of hatred.
是冲动犯罪 A crime of passion.
是原始狂怒 Primal fury.
我们不得不怀疑 We have to wonder.
费尔南多·阿尔维斯有动机 Fernando Alves had motive.
他有机会 他当时在场 He had opportunity. He was there.
他是凶手吗 Is he the killer?
我们能确定吗 不能 Can we know for sure? No.
为什么 Why?
部分原因是他从未被真正调查过 In part, because he was never really investigated.
为什么 Why?
因为在死者体内发现了他的精液 Because his semen was found inside the victim?
他是我们唯一能抓到的人 He's the only one we can get.
应该是他 It shall be him.
并非如此 It's not.
问题是 一旦辩方提出自己的说法 The problem is, once the defense comes up with its own theory,
陪审团希望他们有证据支持 the jury expects that they're gonna have some evidence behind it.
辩方指控受害人的丈夫
关于怀疑是丈夫所为 And the idea that the husband did this,
据我所知 没有证据 there's no evidence for that, as far as I know.
家人来电
喂 Hello?
你今天怎么样 有什么有意思的事吗 How was your day? Anything interesting happen?
我其实没什么可说的 我就是 I don't really have anything to say. I'm...
安静地坐在这里 just sitting here in the quiet.
有点压抑 It's a bit oppressive.
我有点寂寞 I'm a bit lonely.
孩子怎么样 他没事吧 How's the boy? Is he all right?
嗯 我是说 Yeah. I mean...
我得把他的手机拿走 因为他 I'm gonna have to take his iPhone away, because he's...
他没完没了地看报道 而我 He's devouring all the coverage, and I...
那祝你好运 我试过一次 Well, good luck with that. I tried it once,
他变成了《驱魔人》里那个孩子 and he turned into that kid from "The Exorcist."
我吓坏了 就赶紧还给他了 I was so scared, I gave it straight back.
你想不想 Don't suppose you'd like to...
过来喝杯茶 come over for a cup of tea?
来点霜麦片 Boat of Frosties?
我可以做乔纳森式白煮蛋 I could rustle up some "oeuf à la Jonathan."
不了 No.
我知道今天很难熬 I do realize how brutal today was.
尤其因为 Not least because,
你是世上最注重隐私的人 well, there you are, the most private person on the face of the Earth,
经常散着步 人就找不到了 who goes for walks to disappear,
卷进了可怕的马戏团中 真对不起 thrust into the middle of that God-awful circus. I'm sorry.
但我觉得 我们可以重新隐姓埋名 But I do think, I think we can get our anonymity back.
只是计划的问题 Just a question of planning.
我觉得我们应该放纵自己 I think we should, uh, let ourselves go,
肆意变胖 不再打扮 and get really alarmingly fat. Stop grooming.
我觉得你应该穿条非常老土的花呢短裙 I think you should wear extremely frumpy tweed skirts.
事实上 我们都应该 In fact, we both should.
我想我们可以安享晚年了 I, I think we could have a very peaceful old age.
很惨是吧 那是我们相遇时我最大的梦想 Tragic, isn't it? That was my biggest fantasy when we met.
和你一起变老 Getting old with you.
干点老掉牙的事情 比如什么 Doing all the, you know, old stuff. All the...
在花园里闲逛 puttering around the garden, and...
嫌弃年轻人 being spiteful about young people.
加入读书俱乐部 Joining a book club.
不过我们做过啊 But we did that.
你被赶出来了 You got kicked out.
我被开除是因为我很诚实 I was kicked out because I was honest.
那本书烂透了 The book was crap.
你还在听吗 You still there?
在啊 你还记得那些长途电话吗 Yeah, yeah. Do you remember those long phone calls?
即使我们无话可说 我们还是 Even when we had nothing to say, we just...
我们没有挂电话 都聊什么呢 We didn't hang up. What was that about?
我记得 I remember.
是啊 Yeah.
我要睡觉了 I'm gonna go to sleep now.
好的 没问题 再见 Yeah, okay. Bye.
等待 等一下 我 Wait. Um, hang on. I...
我爱你 I love you.
亨利 Henry.
天啊 你吓到我了 My God, you scared me.
-你在干什么 -坐着 - What are you doing? - Sitting.
你去哪了 Where were you?
你为什么坐在这里 Why are you sitting here?
-怎么了 -我睡不着 - What is it? - I couldn't sleep in my bed.
你在想发生的事吗 Were you thinking about it all?
-嗯 -我们撑过了眼下 - Yeah. - We've survived so far.
接下来我们也能撑过去 一定 And we'll survive the rest. We will.
怎么了 What is it?
发生了什么 What's wrong?
有点不对劲 我看得出来 Something's wrong. I can tell.
没有 No. No.
我很好 I'm fine.
不 你有事 No, you're not.
我看见他们了 I saw them.
我看到他们在一起 I saw them together.
在学校 At school.
好吧 Okay.
我应该告诉你的 I should have told you.
如果我告诉你 也许就不会发生了 If I'd told you, maybe it wouldn't have happened.
也许是米格尔的父亲 或者其他嫉妒的人 Maybe Miguel's father, or somebody else who was jealous,
也许他们发现了 maybe if, if, maybe they found out.
-也许如果我告诉你 -这和你没关系 - And maybe if I told you-- - You had nothing to do--
-不 亨利 -那他们就不会 - No. Henry. - Then they wouldn't have--
你能听我说几句吗 Would you just listen for a minute?
米格尔母亲的事与你无关 You had nothing to do with what happened to Miguel's mother.
-不能这么说 -你根本不可能 - You can't say that. - You could never have put--
-就是这样 -不 妈妈 我看到他们了 - I can. - No, but Mom, I saw them.
这对你来说一定很难 And that must have been very hard for you.
他们当时什么都没做 They weren't doing anything.
他们没有接吻 I mean, they weren't kissing,
或者别的什么 但是 or anything, but...
我就是知道 I just knew,
当我看到他们的时候 when I saw them.
我就知道 I knew.
当他看到我时 And when he saw me,
他只是笑了笑 he just smiled.
好像没事一样 Like it was nothing.
他知道我看到了 He saw that I saw.
他知道我知道了 He knew that I knew.
他让你陷入了困境 Well, he put you in a terrible position.
不该让小孩子陷入的境地 A position no child should ever be in.
我想告诉你的 I wanted to tell you.
我想告诉你的 但是 I wanted to tell you, but...
我只是 I just...
我觉得他信任我 I felt like he trusted me.
没事的 It's all right.
你让他看到了 You let him see.
你让他看到你和她在一起 You let him see you with her.
在他学校 At his school.
你知道他看到你了 And you know that he saw you.
-你知道他有多崇拜你 -不是 - You know he did, and he fucking worships you. - No.
他愿意为你做任何事 He would do anything for you.
什么都行 你知道的 Anything. You know that.
别再撒谎了 乔纳森 No more lies, Jonathan.
我知道 知道了 I got it. Yeah. Yeah.
乔纳森 Jonathan.
-在学校啊 -格蕾丝 乔纳森 - At school. - Grace, Jonathan.
我们就要跟本案的警探较量了 We're about to take on the lead detective.
需要成为我的焦点 也需要成为你的焦点 He needs to be my focus, and he needs to be yours.
怎么 我现在要出去吗 What, I'm meant to go out there now?
-像这样坐在外面 -听我说 听我说 - And sit out there like this? - Listen to me. Listen to me.
海莉 Haley.
乔纳森 为什么 Jonathan, why?
-是你害了我们的儿子 -乔纳森 - You did that to our son. - Jonathan.
我们早上8点57分到达现场 We got to the scene at 8:57 a.m.
丈夫报警后的九分钟 Nine minutes after the husband made the 911 call,
大概是在儿子 and about 30 minutes
发现尸体之后的30分钟 after the body was discovered by the son.
你发现了什么 And what did you find?
我们发现了一名女性 已死亡 We discovered a woman, deceased.
头部严重撕裂 Her head badly lacerated,
她的头骨碎了 her skull crushed.
经她丈夫指认 死者为埃琳娜·阿尔维斯 Identified as Elena Alves by her husband.
尽管面部识别已经非常困难了 Though any facial recognition was difficult to discern.
好 我想给你看一组照片 Yes. I'd like to show you a series of photographs.
抱歉 看不下去 I'm sorry, I can't...
这组照片是否公平准确 Do these photographs fairly and accurately
呈现了犯罪现场 represent the crime scene as you found it?
是的 They do.
谢谢 Thank you.
肃静 Order in the court.
没事的 没事的 It's okay. It's okay.
你提到的法医证据 警探 The forensic evidence you spoke of, Detective.
我委托人的精子 唾液和皮肤碎片 My client's sperm, saliva, and skin fragments.
它们都可能是乔纳森·弗雷泽 They could all be the product of Jonathan Fraser's
和埃琳娜·阿尔维斯发生关系的证据 对吗 and Elena Alves' having sex. True?
那也解释不了她头骨碎裂的原因 That would not explain her crushed skull.
当然解释不了 No, it wouldn't.
然而 当斯坦珀女士要求 And yet, when asked by Ms. Stamper
提供证据证明是谁击碎受害人头骨时 to give evidence as to who crushed that skull,
你指证我当事人的证据是 the evidence you gave to incriminate my client is...
精子 唾液和皮肤碎片 sperm, saliva, and skin fragments.
还有他血淋淋的脚印 And his bloody footprints.
可能是他在她被杀后 Which he could have left if he'd returned to the scene
回到现场留下的 after she was killed.
以及你的委托人逃跑的事实 And the fact that your client fled.
是的 他逃走了 Yes, he fled.
我想如果有两个人来到现场 I suppose when we have two people come upon the scene,
一个逃跑了 另一个没有 one flees, the other doesn't,
通常逃跑的人会被送上法庭 it's usually the one who flees who gets put on trial.
没那么简单 It's not as simple as that.
这个案件中 In this case,
它是 it is.
当时没有目击证人 There were no eyewitnesses to this crime.
那栋楼里没有监控摄像头 No security cameras in this building
监控人员出入情况 to monitor the comings and goings.
看看有没有其他人进出 To see if anybody else came or went.
没有 There were not.
那些脚印 The footprints,
现场发现的指纹和唾液 fingerprints, and saliva found at the scene,
属于两个人 belonging to two people.
我的委托人和死者丈夫 My client, and the husband.
费尔南多·阿尔维斯在他儿子报警后去的现场 Fernando Alves went to the scene after his son alerted him.
他是去救他妻子 He went to his wife's aid.
-他是想 -他的DNA - He tried-- - His DNA.
死者丈夫费尔南多·阿尔维斯的DNA The DNA that belonged to the husband, Fernando Alves.
你不能科学地排除 You cannot scientifically exclude the possibility
是前天晚上留下的可能性 对吗 it was left the night before. Can you?
-你没听到我的问题吗 警探 -听到了 - Did you not hear my question, Detective? - I did.
我听到你的问题了 I did hear your question.
我还听到了你的开庭陈述 And I also heard your opening statement.
相当无礼 It was offensive.
我们不会为了快速定罪 We don't stick our heads into sand
就自欺欺人 in order to jam through quick convictions.
一个无辜的人被杀害了 An innocent person got slaughtered.
我们的目的是找出凶手 Our intent was to find out who did it.
我们唯一的追求就是真相 Our only pursuit here was the truth.
-不管你有多失望 -而事实是 - However much that disappoints you. - And the truth is...
-那个人的DNA -他有不在场证明 - that man's DNA-- - He had an alibi.
-一个有动机的人 -他儿子和他在一起 - A man with motive. - His son was with him.
他们俩住的公寓距离 They were together at the family apartment
十个街区外 over 10 blocks away.
他十岁的儿子 His 10-year-old son.
他是一直都醒着吗 He was awake the whole time?
大楼内外都有摄像头 There are cameras in and outside the building
如果阿尔维斯先生离开过 会有录像 that would have shown if Mr. Alves left.
后面和前面都有摄像头 Cameras in the back, as well as the front.
他可能从后门走了 He could have gone out the back.
没有相关证据 There is no evidence,
无论是监控摄像头 either by security cameras,
街上的摄像头 或目击者的描述 street cameras, or eyewitness accounts,
都没有证据表明阿尔维斯那晚在案发现场或附近 that place Mr. Alves on, or around the scene that night.
然而 街道摄像头 Street cameras, however,
确实拍到了你的委托人 did capture your client.
还拍到其他人吗 Anybody else?
没有 No.
这是在哪拍的 Where was this taken?
一个街区之外 A full block away.
-距离案发现场吗 -是的 - From the scene? - Yes.
什么时候 At what time?
晚上九点半多一点 A little past 9:30 p.m.
-案发当晚 -是的 - The night of the murder? - Yes.
案发现场一个街区之外 案发当时 A block from the scene, and at the time of the murder.
照片里的人是谁 你知道吗 Who is this in the picture? Do you know?
格蕾丝·弗雷泽 Grace Fraser.
被告的妻子 The defendant's wife.
当时就在案发现场附近 Near the scene, at around the time.
天啊 Gee.
你意思是她杀了她吗 Are you suggesting she killed her?
我不是这个意思 I'm actually not.
我的意思是你刚刚撒谎了 What I am suggesting is that you just lied.
我是说你有其他人的证据 I'm suggesting that you had evidence of another person,
此人有多重动机 one with a lot of motive,
于案发时间出现在案发现场或附近 being at or near the scene around the time of death,
而你从来没把她作为嫌疑人审问过 and you never bothered to question her as a suspect.
我们当然审问过她 We absolutely questioned her.
作为嫌疑人 As a suspect?
你向她宣读米兰达权利了 You gave her Miranda?
你是否向格蕾丝·弗雷泽宣读过米兰达权利 Did you advise Grace Fraser of her Miranda rights
并把她列为嫌疑人 before questioning her as a suspect?
我们没有 We did not.
如果你认为她是嫌犯 这难道不是法律要求吗 Wouldn't that be the law if you considered her to be a suspect?
宣读她的权利 To read her her rights?
如果她是嫌疑人的话 It would be, if she was a suspect.
但她不是 But she wasn't.
我们有监控录像拍到她在走路 We had security cameras capturing her walking.
一直在走 Continuing on.
我们至今没有证据证明 We had and still have no reason to believe
她进过那间公寓 she ever entered the dwelling,
也没有发现她的DNA nor there was any of her DNA present.
如果发现她的DNA If her DNA had been present,
你会把她当成嫌疑人吗 you would have considered her a suspect?
当然 但事实并非如此 Of course. But it wasn't.
发现他的了 His was.
你向费尔南多宣读过他的权利吗 Did you ever read Fernando his rights?
你为费尔南多·阿尔维斯破例了 You made an exception for Fernando Alves.
是不是因为承认你对他的怀疑 Was it because admitting your suspicions of him
就会降低你抓住他的机会 might weaken your chances of getting him?
费尔南多·阿尔维斯 Fernando Alves
有不在场证明 had an alibi.
对 他熟睡的儿子 Yes. His sleeping son.
-爸爸 -嗯 - Dad. - Yeah.
他们说这个警探是蠕虫 They're calling, uh, the detective a squirmy worm.
他们说"整个案子靠一只蠕虫来办 They're saying, like, "Can't make the prosecutor feel good
检察官怎么可能满意" having your whole case ride on a squirmy worm."
把手机关了 Turn the phone off.
关掉吧 谢谢了 Just turn it off. Thank you.
我们三个很少能一起吃饭 It's not often that we get to eat together, the three of us.
他自己会倒 谢谢 He'll pour it. Thank you.
谢谢 Thank you.
你知道她会这么做吗 Did you know she was gonna do that?
调出那张照片 Pull up that picture?
我知道 I did.
你觉得自己有嫌疑没问题吗 And you're okay being a suspect?
我没有嫌疑 I'm not a suspect.
海莉就是这个意思 就是 That was Haley's point. That--
他们应该更严肃对待我 They should have taken a more serious look at me,
就像他们应该更严肃对待阿尔维斯先生一样 just as they should have taken a more serious look at Mr. Alves.
但他们没有 他们只是对你父亲有狭隘偏见 And they didn't. They just had tunnel vision for your father.
亨利 你妈妈告诉我 So, Hen, uh, your mom told me
你看到了我和 that you saw me and--
我和埃琳娜·阿尔维斯在学校 Me and Elena Alves at school.
我真的很抱歉 And I'm really sorry about that.
我的行为非常恶劣 I behaved incredibly badly.
我很不愿意 It was repugnant of me
让你看到这一切 to allow you to witness anything.
我觉得我们会赢的 I think we're gonna win.
你呢 Do you?
我不知道 I, I don't know.
谢谢 Thank you.
我不知道 I don't-- I don't know,
但我觉得我们可能犯了个大错 but I think we might have made a colossal mistake.
我觉得阿尔维斯先生显然值得同情 I think Mr. Alves is obviously very sympathetic,
也没有确凿的证据表明他有罪 所以 and there's no real evidence to show his guilt. So...
你是认真说的吗 Did you mean what you said?
我们撑过了眼下 接下来我们也能撑过去 If we survived this far, we can survive anything?
是我说的吗 I said that?
昨晚说的 Last night.
如果我们能撑过这场庭审 If we can survive this trial,
我觉得咱们家就能撑过去 I think this family can survive.
-好吧 不过 -你不觉得吗 - All right, but-- - Don't you?
我 Well, I--
-我们改天再谈这些吧 -不要 - We need to talk about that another time. - No.
我现在就想谈 I want to talk about it now.
不 我们现在不谈这个 No, we're not talking about it now.
-现在不是时候 -你告诉你的病人 - It's not the time. - You tell your patients
婚姻可以继续 that marriages can go on,
-即使有人出轨了 -亨利 别这样 - even after somebody cheats. - Henry, come on.
你告诉他们婚姻有时甚至会变得更坚固 You tell them that marriages can even sometimes grow stronger.
-你在撒谎吗 -我说了现在不是时候 - Is that a lie? - I said it's not the time.
-你是撒谎还是你真的相信 -亨利 别说了 停 - Is that a lie, or do you believe that? - Henry, stop. Stop.
你再也不会出轨了 你愿意吗 You would never cheat again. Would you?
-当然不会 -你绝不会再出轨 - No. No. - You would never cheat--
-看到没 看到没 -亨利 - See? See? - Henry.
我们还是一家人 We can still be a family.
我们甚至可以养条狗 Uh, you know, we could even get a dog.
终于 Finally.
我会照顾好的 I'll take care of it,
这样你就不用担心之前发生的事了 so you won't have to worry about what happened before.
什么意思 What do you mean?
我问了你一个问题 I asked you a question.
你说的什么意思 What do you mean?
妈妈跟我说了狗的事 Mom told me about the dog thing.
你的家人怪你 About your family blaming you.
她不该说那些的 Well, she shouldn't have done that.
我出去透透气 Uh, you know, I'm gonna get some air.
我说什么了 What did I say?
妈妈 我说什么了 Mom, what did I say?
没事的 在这等着 It's all right. Just wait here.
乔纳森 Jonathan.
乔纳森 Jonathan!
我很抱歉 我只是压力太大了 I'm sorry. It was just the stress of it all. I, i...
我想这就是自食恶果吧 Taking its toll, I suppose.
我不相信你 I don't believe you.
刚才是怎么回事 What was that about?
乔纳森 怎么了 Jonathan, what...
到底怎么回事 was that about?
我没杀过家里的狗 I, I didn't kill the family dog.
我们从没养过狗 We never had a dog.
我有个妹妹 我 I had a sister. I, I...
我杀了妹妹 I, I killed the family sister.
什么 What?
凯蒂 Katie.
我们叫她小凯蒂 Katie the Kitten, we called her.
我当时在看着她 Um, I was babysitting her.
我当时14岁 她 I was 14. She was, uh,
四岁 four.
然后 And, uh,
不知怎的 她就溜出家了 somehow she sneaked out of the house
当我在厨房做那个 while I was in the kitchen making a...
芝士番茄三明治 a cheese and tomato sandwich.
我听到了刹车声 I heard the sound of the brakes,
然后 有一个声音 and then, um, another sound
我永远无法从脑海中抹去 that I will never... uh, get out of my head.
你妹妹被车撞了 Your sister got hit by a car?
是你妹妹吗 It was your sister?
你应该把这个加到我的谎言清单里 You should add that to my list of lies.
但我也告诉自己 Except I also tell myself this one.
那不是我的错 You know, that it wasn't my fault.
那只是件不幸的意外 That, uh, it was just an unfortunate thing,
但当然了 都是我的错 but, of course, it was my fucking fault,
因为凯蒂 because Katie--
当时是由我照顾小凯蒂 Katie the Kitten was put under my charge.
但是她 And she...
我给自己做点心时 她被车撞了 And she got hit by a car when I was making myself a snack.
你怎么从没告诉过我 How is it you have never told me this?
因为我们对此避而不谈 Because we don't-- we don't talk of it.
你知道的 从不谈 You know. Ever.
永远不会 Ever.
可能是 It's probably, uh...
我为什么选择儿科 why I went into pediatric medicine.
我也不知道 你是心理医生 I don't know. You're, you're the shrink.
你比我清楚 但我跟你说吧 You know better than me, but, uh, I will tell you this.
每一个我治疗的每个病人 每一个 Every... every patient I treat, every s-single one...
都是小凯蒂 is... is little Katie.
嗯 Yeah.
一直以来他都背负着这个包袱 我却从未发现 All this time, he was carrying that burden, and I never saw.
从你的专业角度来看 In your professional opinion,
过去的创伤 is a past trauma like that
可能会让一个人 likely to render a person
更有同情心 more compassionate?
还是更疯狂呢 Or more psychotic?
我给他妈妈打过电话 I tried calling his mother.
好几次 A few times.
但她从没回过 And she never returned.
连他的家人都不想跟他扯上关系 Even his family doesn't want to have anything to do with him.
请转身 Turn, please.
谢谢 Thank you.
请转身 Turn, please.
谢谢 Thank you.
早上好 Morning.
请转身 Turn, please.
-谢谢 先生 -不客气 - Thank you, sir. - Yeah.
请转身 Turn, please.
她没回家 After she hadn't come home,
也不回我的电话或短信 or replied to any of my calls or texts,
我儿子米格尔去找她了 my son Miguel, he went to check on her.
我以为他去上学了 I, I thought he'd gone to school.
我早上带孩子所以很忙 I was just having a busy morning with the baby.
她又不在 所以 She wasn't there, so,
我让他赶紧走 I told him to just go on.
他自己去坐车 但他没有 See himself to the bus. And he didn't.
他去找他妈妈了 He went to see his mom.
他去了工作室 He went to the studio.
是的 Yes.
然后你去了那里 And then you went there.
是的 Yes.
在他回来之后 After he'd come back.
他当时 He was...
哭泣 尖叫 crying, screaming.
- 所以你去了那里 然后 -是的 - And so you went there, and-- - Yeah.
你发现了什么 What did you find?
就是 It's...
埃琳娜 Elena.
我的妻子 My wife.
她就躺在那里 She was just lying there.
到处都是血 There was just blood everywhere.
她的脸 Her face,
她的头都变成糊状了 head. They were like mush.
所以你就报警了 So you called the police?
是的 我报了警 还有 Yeah. I called the police, and...
救护车 ambulance.
谢谢 Thank you.
阿尔维斯先生 Mr. Alves.
我无法想象你的痛苦 先生 I cannot imagine your pain, sir.
你说谎 That's a lie.
你说什么 I'm sorry?
你对我毫无感觉 You feel nothing for me.
或是我的痛苦 Or my pain.
你想怪我头上 You tried to blame me.
其实我没有 I actually didn't.
我只是想指出 I simply tried to point out
不能排除你的嫌疑 that you cannot be eliminated as a suspect.
不能排除其他人的嫌疑 That others cannot be eliminated.
因此 你该鄙视的警察 不是我 For that, you should direct your contempt to the police. Not me.
-反对 -反对有效 - Objection. - Sustained.
我妻子死了 而你只是 See, my wife is dead, and, and you're just...
玩把戏 playing games.
就是这样 That's it.
你让我恶心 You disgust me.
我不想激怒你 I don't mean to incite your rage.
你说过你爱埃琳娜 You spoke of your love of Elena.
你很爱她 You loved her very much.
她是我的一切 She was everything to me.
我感觉到了 I'm sensing that.
但你不是她的全部 But you weren't everything to her.
她还有其他男人 And there were other men.
-包括我的委托人 -不 不 不 - Including my client. - No, no, no.
没有其他男人 There were no other men.
就他一个 He was the only one.
-你怎么知道的 先生 -因为我就是知道 - How can you know that, sir? - Well, because I do.
你知道她和乔纳森有情感关系吗 Did you know that she was romantically involved with Jonathan?
埃琳娜对你有所隐瞒 Elena was able to keep part of herself from you.
也许这就是为什么她单独有间公寓 Maybe that's why she kept a separate apartment.
跟你保持距离 To keep part of her separate.
不 不是这样的 No, that's not what that was.
那个公寓是她用来搞创作的 That was an apartment for her art,
因为她是个艺术家 所以 because she was an artist, and--
她需要专注 需要工作 And she needed to focus and she needed to work.
那间公寓就是干这个的 That's what that apartment was for.
不只是为了她的艺术 It wasn't just for her art.
她一直在用它和我的委托人搞外遇 She'd been using it to have an affair with my client.
你知道吗 先生 Did you know, sir?
一开始不知道 Not at first.
但有一天 But at some point?
在某个时刻 你发现你的女儿 And at some point, you learned that your daughter...
我的委托人是孩子的生父 That my client was the biological father.
你一定很难以接受 That must have been an awful thing to learn.
请原谅 但我必须要问 Forgive me, but I have to ask.
你妻子接受过精神治疗吗 Was your wife receiving any psychiatric treatment?
反对 Objection.
反对无效 Overruled.
接受过吗 Was she?
-是的 -为什么 你知道吗 - Yes. - What for? Do you know?
你真卑鄙 You are vile.
我只是想证明凶手可能另有他人 My question only goes to who else could have possibly done this.
我们不能排除她和其他男人约会的可能性 We cannot rule out that she saw other men.
也许有一个这样的人 That maybe one such man
可能他会爆发嫉妒心 had the capacity for explosive jealousy,
-或是暴怒 -反对 - or violent rage. - Objection!
这些正是你想让警察问的问题 These are the very questions you'd want the police asking.
-我能查出是谁干的吗 -法官大人 - Am I right to find out who did this? - Your honor--
-是他干的 是他干的 -法官大人 我能上前 - He did this! He did this! - Your, your honor, may I approach--
阿尔维斯先生 Mr. Alves,
你接受过精神治疗吗 are you receiving any psychiatric help?
-反对 -我不想这么冷血 - Objection! - I don't mean to be insensitive.
那你表现得还真好 Well, you're doing a great job of it.
是你让这位证人出庭作证的 You have put this witness on the stand.
-法官大人 我有话要说 -接受质证 - Your honor, may I approach? - It's cross-examination.
阿尔维斯先生 你所经历的一切 Mr. Alves, what you have to be going through,
有人帮你吗 are you getting any help?
法官大人 Your honor...
你觉得怎么样 How do you think it's going?
你的客观意见 Your objective opinion?
对我来说 Look, to, to me,
很有可能 it's more likely than not that...
是乔纳森干的 that Jonathan did it.
但更有可能不是标准 But more likely isn't the standard.
没有任何合理怀疑 It's beyond all reasonable doubt.
那你就有胜算了 That puts you ahead.
而且他还有最好的律师 所以 That, and he has the best attorney money can buy. So...
格蕾丝 我 Grace, I--
我也许不该问你这个 但是 I probably shouldn't ask you this, but--
你到底怎么想的 What are you actually thinking?
是啊 你不该问这个问题 Yeah. You shouldn't ask that.
另一个不可能是我的原因 Another reason I couldn't have done it.
我爱她 I loved her.
非常爱 Quite madly.
我不能对格蕾丝这么说 Not something I could say to Grace, you see.
这并没有减少我对我妻子的爱 只是 It didn't diminish my love for my wife. It was just, uh...
各有不同 different.
进展顺利 但你得出庭作证 It's going well, but you'll need to testify.
我们需要解释你为什么逃跑 We need to account for why you fled.
只有你能做到 Only you can do that.
别假装诚实 因为你撒了太多谎 Don't pretend to be honest, because you've told too many lies.
别假装是个好丈夫 好父亲 Don't pretend to be a good husband, a decent father,
因为你两者都不是 because you are arguably neither.
我们不需要给他们呈现好人 We don't need to give them a good man.
只要一个没有杀人的人 Just someone who didn't commit murder.
珍妮特 Janet.
你好 Hello.
格蕾丝 Grace.
-那边几点了 -现在是凌晨四点 - What time is it there? - It's four a.M.
我睡不着 所以 I couldn't sleep, so,
我想利用这段时间回你电话 I thought I would use the time to return your call.
谢谢你 Well, thank you.
谢谢 我很抱歉 Thank you. I'm sorry it's...
我们好久不见 自从 been so long since we've...
是从婚礼之后 格蕾丝 Since the wedding, Grace.
婚礼后我们就没见过面了 We haven't seen each other since the wedding.
我知道乔纳森的事 Jonathan's doing, I realize.
他怎么样了 How is he?
我无法想象 I can't imagine well.
不好 我们大家都不好 所以 No. None of us are doing great, so...
-每个人 -什么 - Is. - I'm sorry?
我们大家每个人都不好 None of us is doing great.
"大家"是"每个人"的意思 "None" is a contraction of "not one."
是单数 It's singular.
动词得用单数形式 The verb is singular.
还有 亨利 And, um, Henry.
他现在看起来像个大人了吧 He must be looking like a grown man by now?
差不多了 He's getting there.
我给你发了些照片 不过 I've sent you some pictures, but, uh--
格蕾丝 我不怪你 Grace, I don't blame you.
是乔纳森决定放弃家庭成员的身份 It was Jonathan's decision to no longer be part of his family.
早在他遇见你之前就做了这个决定 A decision he made long before he met you.
我现在正试着把所有线索拼凑起来 Well, I'm just trying to piece everything together right now.
你应该能理解 You can probably understand.
是的 我理解 Yes, I can.
我只是 I just...
知道乔纳森曾有个妹妹 learned that Jonathan had a younger sister.
凯蒂 Katie.
他觉得自己对她的死负有责任 And that he feels responsible for her death.
他是应该 As he should.
他有责任 He was responsible.
他让一个四岁的孩子在繁忙的马路上晃荡 He allowed a four-year-old to wander out onto a busy street.
她在马路上被撞死了 Where she was struck dead.
那一定非常可怕 That must have been unspeakably awful.
是的 It was.
珍妮特 Janet, um...
悲伤和内疚 还有 The grief and the guilt, and, and...
乔纳森伴随这些心理长大 Jonathan growing up with that.
他接受过专业治疗吗 Did he ever get professional help?
他没有 He did not.
他也没承受这些 He suffered from neither.
没有愧疚 没有悲伤 No guilt, no grief.
我们一直在等 We kept waiting for it.
我们一家人都支持他 We, uh, surrounded him with family support,
想着一旦震惊消退 certain that once the shock wore off,
痛苦就会开始 the suffering would begin.
但从来没有 But, it never did.
乔纳森不懂难过 Jonathan doesn't know how to suffer.
他妹妹死后 After his sister was killed,
他从没说过对不起 he never even said he was sorry.
他妹妹死后 After his sister was killed,
他什么都没说 he never said another word about it.
他就继续住在家里 He just went on living here,
直到他到了可以离开的年龄 until he was old enough to leave,
然后再也没回来过 and never come back.
他就是这么做的 Which is what he did.
她叫凯蒂 是他干的 Her name was Katie, and he was responsible.
是他任由她走出家门 ...that he allowed her to wander out of the house...
她才四岁 She was four.
之后 他既没有内疚也没有悲伤 And that after, he suffered neither guilt nor grief.
格蕾丝 我想搞清楚 Grace, I want to be very clear.
我想知道你到底在说什么 I want to understand exactly what you're telling me.
你是说乔纳森的母亲 You're saying that Jonathan's mother
说他既没有罪恶感也没有悲伤 said he suffered from neither guilt, nor grief.
实际上 他的母亲 In essence, his own mother
认定他是反社会者 identified him as a sociopath.
对 Yes.
天啊 Jesus.