六个月前
打扰一下 Excuse me.
一束玫瑰花 十二朵 Roses, a dozen.
我知道 I know.
他说他正要去女朋友家 He said he was heading to his girlfriend's house
可是女朋友临时取消约会了 and she cancelled on him.
没 他连名字都没告诉我 No, didn't even tell me his name.
只说不想浪费了这束花 Just said he didn't want them to go to waste.
还挺不错的 It was nice.
这周过得真糟糕 It's been a lousy week.
也许总算开始时来运转了 Maybe things are finally turning around.
地铁推手
曼哈顿今晚发生一起悲剧 Tragic news out of Manhattan this evening,
一名女子在地铁即将到站时被推下月台 where a young woman was pushed in front of a subway train.
说真的 你们俩的宝宝 Seriously, you guys have, like,
绝对是全纽约最可爱的 the cutest kids in New York.
说的没错 It's true.
念大学的时候谁会想到 Who knew these guys back in college
你俩会这么一个接一个地生 would be such a baby factory?
我 我想到了 Me, I did.
就在我发现他们在我床上滚床单之后 Right after I caught them having sex in my bed.
就一次 大一那年 One time, freshman year.
你还是忘了吧 You must move on.
实话实说吧 Yeah, and let's be honest,
那床一年到头见过最多的"动作"就是这个了 that is the most action that bed saw all year.
周六萨米的生日派对 Are you going to be able to make it
你有空来吗 to Sammy's birthday party on Saturday?
两点钟 当然来 2:00, yes.
周五我和客户做收尾工作 I am wrapping up with my client on Friday
也许我还能过来帮忙布置 and I may be able to help and come set up.
说起来 干得怎么样 How is that going, by the way?
当康戒陪护这回事 The companionship thing.
如果你的"这回事"指的是我的职业 If by "thing" you mean career,
我觉得干得还不错 it is going really well.
我不知道 我的客户都是些很有意思的人 I-I-I don't know, I've worked with some amazing people.
我觉得你的工作太不可思议了 I think it's incredible, what you're doing.
你放弃了做医生 I mean, you walk away from being a doctor,
找到一种帮助别人的全新方式 find a new way to help people?
还是那个老样子的乔 Same old Jo.
真贴心 Sweet.
敬乔恩 敬乔恩 To Joan. To Joan.
还有未出世的宝宝 And the baby.
还有宝宝 And the baby!
抱歉 是把我介绍给其他客户的 Oh, sorry, guys, this is, um, one of the rehab facilities
康戒中心打来的 that, um, refers me to other clients.
我得接一下 I should take it.
马上回来 I'll be right back.
我是乔恩·华生 This is Joan Watson.
乔恩 我是汉德尔康戒中心的卡鲁索医生 Joan, this is Dr. Caruso at Hemdale.
我给你发了一份客户资料 I sent you a case file a little while ago.
你看过了吗 I was wondering if you had a chance to look at it?
我正在打开 I'm just opening it right now.
来自 卡鲁索医生 新客户资料
这位病人 The patient in question
周一完成了在我们这的疗程 completes his stay with us on Monday.
但他的父亲担心他离开康戒中心后的生活 His father expressed some concerns about life post-rehab,
汉德尔康戒中心 出院病人资料
我就向他推荐了康戒陪护 so, I recommended a companion.
他看了几份简历 选中了你 He looked at some resumes and chose you.
我能告诉他你有兴趣接受工作吗 So, can I tell him the interest is mutual?
当然 我只有一个问题 Sure, I just have one question.
夏洛克算是个什么名字 Uh, what kind of name is Sherlock?
现如今
我做不到 I can't do this.
快把它关掉 Ah, just shut it off.
不能让报警声影响你 Can't let the noise get to you.
-你应该知道的 -我知道 - You know this. - I know.
但你这次开锁表现得不错 But you did better with the lock this time.
只花了六秒钟 It took you six seconds.
这太古怪了 How weird is this?
你是夏洛克的担保人 You're Sherlock's sponsor
我是他的康戒 and I'm his sober--
直到最近 我都是他的康戒陪护 well, I was his sober companion-- until recently.
而现在你却在教我怎么开车锁 And now you're teaching me how to break into cars.
谁让你想和他从事同样的工作 You want to do the kind of work he does.
除此之外 我陪你多久 Besides, every hour I spend with you,
他就得陪我两倍的时间 he's got to do two with me.
你们相处得怎么样 How's that going?
还不错 He's good.
他状态很好 He's in a good place.
你决定做他的助手后 他情绪好多了 Happier since you decided to work with him.
来自 夏洛克 华生 需要你 火速来
我得走了 Hey, I gotta go.
我送你一程 I'll give you a ride.
不幸的消息 Dreadful news:
今早接到了我父亲的电话 I heard from my father this morning.
是吗 Really?
当然不是他本人打的 Not the man himself, of course.
一个他的随从打的 One of his minions.
显然 他让我遵守我问他 Apparently, he's holding me to the bargain
借那点小钱的时候达成的约定 that we struck when I borrowed that pittance from him.
如果你是指用来付 If you're referring to the $2.2 million
绑架赎金的那两百二十万 that you borrowed to pay off the kidnapping ransom,
那可不是一点小钱 I'd say that's a little more than a pittance.
我抓住了那个绑架犯 I foiled that kidnapper.
钱全部收回并还给他了 一分不差 Every penny was accounted for and returned.
是 但借钱是事实 Yeah, but still.
你已经不为他干活了 华生 You're off his teats now, Watson,
不用再帮他说话 you can stop taking his side.
他想要什么 What did he want?
他要我今早去见他的众多律师之一 Uh, to meet with one of his many attorneys
讨论一些调查性质的工作 this morning and discuss work of an investigative nature.
我了解我父亲 他是个不折不扣的讼棍 Knowing father, the man is a shyster's shyster.
讼棍 不择手段通过恶意诉讼谋取利益的律师
他帮一个简直是阿道夫·希特勒和 You know, Dad once helped defending a client
伯纳德·麦道夫结合体的客户辩护过 who was equal parts Adolf Hitler and Bernie Madoff.
你父亲知道我还在这儿 Hey, does your father know that I'm still here
并和你一起工作吗 and that we're working together now?
他关心这个干嘛 Why would he care?
不知道 我只是好奇 I don't know, I was just curious.
你现在是个有抱负的侦探了 华生 You're an aspiring detective now, Watson.
把你的好奇心用在案子上 Apply your curiosity to your cases.
真不错 Impressive.
是啊 在这里看一整天风景都不会厌 I know; I could look at this all day.
不 我是说这玻璃窗 No, I was talking about the glass.
是用防弹玻璃做的 It's... bullet-proof.
6英尺厚的聚碳酸酯玻璃幕墙 Six-inch glass-clad polycarbonate, hmm.
福尔摩斯先生 Mr. Holmes.
菲利普·亚米斯德 Philip Armistead.
你知道"讼棍"在德语里 Do you know that "Shyster"
是指"大便的人"吗 is German for "one who defecates"?
这是我的助手丽贝卡 And this is my assistant Rebecca.
让我们开门见山吧 好吗 So, let's cut to the proverbial chase, shall we?
我和我的助手要 How much slime will my associate and I
趟多少浑水才能帮到你 have to wade through in order to help you?
我父亲说你需要我的服务 My father said you were in need of my services.
你是律师 你为他工作 他很看重你 You're an attorney, you work for him, he values you:
从这三点能充分看出 three good reasons to assume
我们要做的一定不是什么好事 that the work we will have to do will be vile.
其实 我希望你能帮助丽贝卡 Actually, I was hoping you might be able to help Rebecca.
我的妹妹凯丽 My sister Callie...
她六个月前失踪了 she went missing almost six months ago.
我担心是她丈夫对她下了毒手 I'm worried her husband may have done something to her.
我想我要先说"对不起" Uh, I guess I should start with "I'm sorry".
我恨自己没勇气当面和你说 I hate that I can't say these things to you face-to-face.
只是... It's just...
我不爱你了 德鲁 I don't love you anymore, Drew.
你知道的 说这话我也不好受 And it hurts to say that, you don't know how much.
我在乎你 我希望你幸福 I care about you, I want you to be happy,
但我自己也想要幸福 but I need to be happy, too.
我以为自己能挺过去 And I thought that I could tough it out
能再多给我俩一点时间 and give us both a little more time.
可看到那个女人被推下地铁月台的事后 But then that woman got pushed in front of a subway train the other day--
那个拿着鲜花的女人 the woman with the flowers--
我不知道 我一直不住地想着她的遭遇 and, I don't know, I couldn't stop thinking about her.
生命太过短暂 不能浪费在 Life is too short to stay with someone
地铁推手
不能带给你幸福的人身上 who doesn't make you happy.
所以我决定离开一段时间 So, uh, I'm going to go away for a little while.
地铁推手 女子 鲜花
我不知道要去哪 也不知道去多久 I don't know where and I-I don't know for how long.
男子向女子献花后 将其推下月台
我只知道我需要时间静一静 I just know that I need some time.
也许有一天 Maybe, someday, you'll find it
你能从内心深处原谅我 in your heart to forgive me.
我妹夫第一次给我看这段视频的时候 When my brother-in-law Drew first showed me the video,
我没觉得有问题 I didn't question it.
凯丽一直有点多愁善感 Callie had always been a little fragile.
收拾行李 出去散散心 Packing up her stuff and hiding out for a while,
确实像她会做的事 that sounded like her.
但几天过去 又过了几周 But then after the days started turning into weeks,
我起了疑心 I got suspicious.
他们的婚姻 出了状况吗 The marriage was... troubled?
凯丽和他分开过一次 Callie had left him once before.
大概是一年半之前 That was about a year and a half ago.
是怎么回事 What happened?
我不知道 凯丽在几周以后 I don't know. Callie didn't even tell me
才告诉我那事 she'd done it till a few weeks later,
但那时 她和德鲁又和好了 and by then, she and Drew were back together.
我试过让她告诉我缘由 And I tried to get her to talk about it,
可她说事情已经过去了 but she said it was all in the past.
她就是喜欢 She was like that--
把什么事都压在心里 不告诉别人 she kept everything bottled up; private.
所以德鲁给我看过视频之后 So, when she didn't return my phone calls
我不奇怪她没接我电话 after Drew showed me the video, I wasn't surprised.
几周之后 丽贝卡报了警 After a few weeks, Rebecca went to the police.
他们试图通过凯丽的手机 信用卡 They tried to locate Callie via her cell phone,
和电子邮件记录找到她 credit card, e-mail records,
但是徒劳无果 but they came up empty.
自从失踪以来她就没用过上述任何东西 She hadn't used any of them since before she disappeared.
他们质问了德鲁 但是他设法说服了他们 They questioned Drew, but he managed to convince them
视频是真的 the video was authentic.
那你认为它是假的 Oh, you-you think it's a fake?
我认为德鲁和我妹妹的关系很糟 I think things were bad between Drew and my sister.
他可能强迫她拍了那个视频 He could've forced her to make the video
这样一来 他杀掉她之后 so that, after he killed her,
他就能给警察看视频 并说服警察 he could show it to the police and convince them
她是自己离开的 that she'd run away.
他就是这么做的 Which he did.
还有这箱子 There's also the trunk.
它是我们祖母的 It was our grandmother's.
我父亲去世之前将其过继给了我 My father willed it to me before he died.
我的公寓很小 所以我让凯丽 My apartment is tiny, so I let Callie
替我保管 keep it at her place.
我们说好 The deal was,
如果我搬家了她就把箱子还给我 she would give it to me if I ever moved.
她失踪以后 The first time that I went
我第一次去找德鲁的时候 to see Drew after she disappeared,
发现那个箱子也不见了 I realized that the trunk was gone, too.
他声称她将其一并带走了 He claimed that she took it with her,
但我知道她不会这么做的 but I know that she would never do that.
我告诉警察说我认为他杀了我妹妹 I told the police that I think he did what he did.
并用箱子弃尸 And he used the trunk to get rid of her.
我让公司里最好的侦探 I've had the firm's top investigators
查了几个月了 on this for months.
他们至今没查出任何东西 They haven't managed to come up with anything.
几天前我碰巧跟你父亲聊到 I happened to speak with your father the other day,
他推荐我来找你 and he recommended I reach out to you.
介意我们失陪一下吗 Would you excuse us for just one moment?
走吧 Come on.
关于她妹妹的视频 That woman could not be more wrong
那女人简直大错特错 about her sister's video.
它绝对不是被胁迫的产物 It was most certainly not made under duress.
说来听听 Tell me.
人的脸啊 华生 就跟阳具一样 The human face, Watson, is like the penis.
伟大的人格理论学家希尔文·汤姆金斯是这么说的 Or so said the great personality theorist Silvan Tomkins.
美国著名心理学家兼人格理论学家
他的观点是 The point being:
人的脸跟男性生殖器一样 the face, like the male member,
是有自主意识的 它几乎每天 has a mind of its own; it betrays us
都背叛我们 将我们的秘密 on an almost daily basis; advertises our secrets
显露给知道要找什么的人 to those who know what to look for.
拍摄视频的时候 那女人 The woman in that video was utterly calm
十分冷静 when she filmed it.
不止如此 我认为她对开始新生活还很兴奋 More than that, I think she was excited to move on.
你和我看的不是同一个视频吧 You and I were not looking at the same video.
她的颚肌是放松的 不紧张 Her jaw muscles were relaxed, not tight.
她的鼻翼没有扩张 Her nose wings were not dilated.
她不是在念稿子 She wasn't going off some script,
她说的每一个字都发自肺腑 she meant every word she was saying.
-鼻翼 -我们遇到了一个机会 华生 - Nose wings. - We have an opportunity here, Watson.
更准确来说 是你 More precisely, you do.
我认为这会是你极好的处女作 I think this would make an excellent first case for you.
你想让我凭一己之力找到凯丽·伯勒尔 You want me to find Callie Burrell on my own?
每一个优秀的侦探都要有能力 Every good investigator needs to be able to find people
找到不想被找到的人 who do not wish to be found.
在大多数情况下 他们是危险的罪犯 More often than not, those are dangerous criminals.
而伯勒尔夫人不过就是个厌恶了丈夫的妻子 Ms. Burrell is merely a wife grown tired of her husband.
这案子非常明了 It's a case with training wheels.
你不能肯定凯丽就没事 You can't be sure that Callie is okay.
你知道吗 她姐姐说的话 And, you know what, th-th-there might be something
或许有些是对的 to what her sister is saying.
或许是 或许不是 要靠你来找出答案 Maybe, maybe not. Your job to find out.
是因为这个案件是你父亲交给你的吗 Is this because the case came through your father?
不 是因为它适合你 No, it's because the case suits you.
再说 我自己还有一个想调查的案件 Besides, I have one of my own which I wish to take up.
是凯丽在视频中提到的女人 Oh, that's the woman that Callie mentioned in her video.
她就在凯丽"失踪"的 She was murdered just days before Callie
几天前遇害了 quote-unquote vanished.
一直没找到推她的男人 The man who pushed her was never found.
在伦敦时 我因为地铁推手失去了一位珍贵的线人 I lost a valued informant to a pusher back in London.
可怕的下场 Ugly business, yeah.
你能想象的最糟糕的死亡方式不过如此 As horrific a death as you can imagine.
我找到了那个杀手 Now, I found that killer.
我认为我也能找到这个杀手 I suspect I can find this one as well.
你不打算告诉 Hey, aren't you going to tell
你父亲的朋友我们的打算吗 your father's friend what we're doing?
现在是你的案件了 华生 Your case now, Watson.
你去告诉他 You tell him.
福尔摩斯 演绎法
第一季 第十八集
人人影视 YYeTs.com
原创翻译 双语字幕
■
仅供学习 禁止用于任何商业盈利行为 更多影视更新 请登陆www.YYeTs.com
翻译：cindysheva 催眠大师 dolphinzx 陈小圈 Michael 面条打包子
我得承认 这个案件发生时 I must confess, I'm quite embarrassed
我竟没留意到 真惭愧 this murder escaped my attention when it first transpired.
校对：Chique 陈小圈 总监 陈小圈
后期：Xaviano 时间轴：加森 又又 密斯恩
我当时还被关在汉德尔 I was still locked away in Hemdale at the time.
说关着有点夸张吧 "Locked away" is a little exaggerated.
就在我到那的几天后 When in days of my arrival,
工作人员就禁止了我看报纸 the staff forbade me access to newspapers.
报纸上警情通报的一些内容激怒了我 Something about police blotters riling me.
-不会吧 你 -这起案子很稀奇 - No, you? - Curious case, this one.
男人接近女人 Man approaches woman.
男人送女人花 Man gives woman flowers.
然后走开 但是片刻之后回来 And walks away, only to return moments later
将女人推到了列车前 and push woman in front of train.
很明显这家伙是个精神病 It's pretty obvious the guy's a psychopath.
的确有可能 Likely, yeah.
但并不明显 Obvious, no.
他谨慎小心地让自己的脸 He takes great care to keep his face
不被月台上的摄像机拍到 angled away from the platform security cameras.
证明他有预谋 Speaks to premeditation.
他之前去过月台 并勘察了地形 He'd been to the platform before and cased it.
-精神病不会预谋吗 -不 他们当然可以了 - Psychopaths can't premeditate? - No, of course they can.
但是地铁推手有疯子的倾向 But tube pushers tend to be lunatics
是疯狂十足的那种 of the raving variety.
他们很大意 They're sloppy.
这个男人却完全相反 This man was the opposite.
好消息是 Good news is...
我完全知道他的长相了 ...I know exactly what he looks like.
你是认真的吗 Look, I can't tell if you're kidding right now or not.
我去找帮助画出画像的目击证人 I reached out to the witnesses who helped generate
完全没用 that sketch-- completely useless,
尤其是关于他的夹克上 especially with regards to the patch
这个位置有个袖章 看起来像是某种商标 he has on his jacket here-- looks like some sort of logo.
无法判断那是什么 I can't tell what it is.
你认为你能从一个袖章找到人吗 You think you can find the guy from a patch?
更怪的事都有 华生 Stranger things, Watson.
你寻找我父亲的律师的 How goes the search
助手的妹妹的事进展如何了 for father's lawyer's assistant's sister?
我仔细看过了 Well... I went through
公司侦探调查到的 everything that the firm's investigators
所有资料 目前为止毫无发现 have put together, and so far, nothing.
我是说 如果她真的是在躲避她的丈夫 I mean, if she's really hiding from her husband,
那她干得真棒 she's doing a bang-up job.
我能明白为什么警察停止了搜索 I can see why the police called off the search.
-你跟丈夫谈过了吗 -没 我今天 - Have you spoken to the husband yet? - No, I called
给他的画廊打电话 他出差了 his art gallery today, and he's out of town.
我明天会亲自登门造访 I'm gonna pop in tomorrow
尽力扮演好我的侦探角色 and do my best Columbo impression.
《神探科伦坡》是美国长寿侦探剧集
科伦坡是... He was a...
当我什么都没说 Never mind.
我为你感到兴奋 I'm excited for you.
当你跟他交谈时 你会把自己 When you talk to him, you'll identify yourself
当成顾问侦探一样 as a "consulting detective."
-这是你第一次 -我 - You haven't done that before. - I...
艾米莉·汉金斯来电
糟糕 Oh, no.
我应该在八点 Carver and Sons.
去卡佛尔一家见你的 8 o'clock, I was supposed to meet you.
我大胆地猜一下 你是忘了吧 I'm gonna go out on a limb and say you forgot.
-听着 我 -没事 又不是 - Look, Em, I... - It's okay. It's not like
上一次我们约好时你就放了我鸽子 you forgot to meet me the last time we made plans.
不 等等 你的确这么做了 Oh, no, wait, you did.
让我补偿你吧 明天 我请客 Let me make it up to you-- uh, tomorrow, my treat.
-算了吧 乔恩 -别嘛 我真抱歉 - I don't know, Joan. - Come on. I feel awful.
那好吧 Know what? Yeah.
明天应该行 咱们八点见 Tomorrow should work. I'll see you at 8:00.
好的 棒极了 到时候见 Okay, great. I'll see you then.
加德纳先生 我是乔恩·华生 Mr. Gardner? Hi. I'm Joan Watson.
我是顾问 I'm consulting, uh...
我 我在协助调查 I-I'm assisting with an investigation
你妻子失踪一案 into the disappearance of your wife.
我在想能不能问你几个问题 I was wondering if I could ask you a few questions?
当然可以 进来吧 Of course. Come in.
我以为凯丽离开我 I thought Callie leaving me
是可能发生的最糟糕的事了 was the worst thing that could ever happen.
我错了 最糟糕的是 I was wrong-- the worst part was...
得知到丽贝卡以为我会伤害她 realizing Rebecca thought I'd hurt her.
你觉得凯丽自离开以来没跟 Do you think it's strange that Callie hasn't tried
你或丽贝卡联系过 这奇怪吗 to contact you or Rebecca since she left?
是 Yeah.
我猜是的 I guess I do.
但是 这比我发现她收拾了她的东西 But... do I find it stranger than her packing her things
并且以视频的形式 and sending me a Dear John letter
给我发了封分手信还要奇怪吗 不 in the form of a video? No.
她一直是个非常 She's always been a very...
复杂的人 complicated person.
丽贝卡提到她之前也离开过你 Rebecca mentioned that Callie left you once before?
大约在一年半以前 About a year and half ago.
只是一两天 不过还是 It was just for a couple of days, but still...
令人心碎 it was devastating.
那次她给我打电话了 That time she called me.
我央求她回家 我告诉她 I begged her to come home. I told her
不管有什么烦恼 我们一起解决 whatever was bothering her, we could work it out.
我想我说动了她 因为之后她回家了 I guess I got through to her, because she came back.
如果你不介意我问的话 If you don't mind me asking,
你们之间的问题是什么 what were the problems between you?
我不知道 I don't know.
她第一次出走 对我来说 The first time she left, it was like
好像当头一棒 being hit over the head with a club.
我以为我们相处得很好 I thought things were good between us.
我以为我们当时的关系很好 I thought we were in a good place.
很明显 我错了 Obviously, I was wrong.
那第二次离家出走呢 And what about the second time?
她有些疏远 She seemed a little distant of late.
-有些低落 -你知道原因吗 - A little depressed. - Do you know why?
是和那个被推向地铁车轨 Something to do with that woman
的女人有关 who got pushed in front of the subway car.
也就是她在视频里说的那个人 The one she talked about in the video.
丽贝卡提到有一个箱子不见了 Rebecca also mentioned something about a trunk that went missing.
不是不见了 是凯丽带走了 It didn't go missing. Callie took it.
我不知道我要说多少遍 I don't know how many times Rebecca has to hear it
丽贝卡才能相信 until she believes it.
我希望我能 I just wish I could make
让她明白 我也想让凯丽回来 her understand that I want Callie back, too.
不是为了挽救我们的婚姻 Not because I think our marriage can be saved,
我知道那已经不可能了 I know that ship has sailed,
是因为我很担心她 but because I'm worried about her.
我想告诉她这没关系 I want to tell her that it's okay,
我希望她能开心 that I want her to be happy.
即使这意味着她要和别人在一起 Even if being happy means being with somebody else.
-华生 -记得你昨天和我说 - Watson? - Remember how you said yesterday
你认为凯丽·伯勒尔有可能没事吗 you thought Callie Burrell was probably okay?
-我记得 -我想你猜错了 - I do. - I'm pretty sure that's not right.
我确信她丈夫杀了她 I'm pretty sure her husband killed her.
是因为我很担心她 But because I'm worried about her.
我想告诉她这没关系 I wanna tell her that it's okay,
我希望她能开心 that I want her to be happy.
即使这意味着 Even if being happy means
她要和别人在一起 being with somebody else.
这是警察五个月前审讯 That was recorded by the police the first time
德鲁·加德纳的录音记录 they interviewed Drew Gardner five months ago.
这和他今早说的话一模一样 He said the same exact thing to me this morning.
-一字不差的 -因为他说了一样的话 - Verbatim. - And because he repeated himself,
所以你认为他是凶手 you think he's a murderer.
不 不是因为他说了一样的话 No, it's not because he repeated himself,
但他的话就像是演练过一样 it's just that what he said sounded rehearsed-- like
就好像他已经编好故事 张口就来 like he came up with his story and then stuck with it.
也许是因为重复的次数太多 Perhaps it's lodged in his brain
已经深印在脑海里了 because he's had to repeat it so often.
对他的小姨子说过 对警察说过 To his sister-in-law, to the police,
对他的朋友 同事 还有你都说过 to his friends, to his colleagues, to you.
我不是在质疑你的判断 你可能是对的 I'm not poking holes. You may very well be right.
我只希望你能仔细想清楚了 I just want to be certain that you've thought this through.
我也不知道他哪儿有问题 There's just something about this guy,
哪里让我讨厌 something I didn't like.
假设你的推理是正确的 Let's say your assessment of the man is correct.
他是个粗人 是个杀手 那么 He is a cad and a killer. That would mean the stakes
本次调查的利害关系就更复杂了 of this investigation have just been raised.
需要我介入吗 Would you like me to tag in?
不用 No.
暂时不用 No, not yet.
如果你在调查这个案子 If you were working this case,
你下一步要做什么 what would your next step be?
你有加德纳先生的电话吗 Do you have Mr. Gardner's cell number handy?
装神弄鬼 Gaslighting.
这是一种心理虐待 A form of psychological abuse
将错误的信息呈现在对方面前 in which false information is presented
让对方感到迷惑 with the intention of disorienting a victim,
从而引导他做出某些行为 and/or steering them on a certain course of action.
名字来自1938年的舞台剧《煤气灯下》 The name derives from the 1938 stage play Gaslight,
也叫做《天使街》 also known as Angel Street.
你怎么有这么多手机 Why do you have so many phones?
那你为什么只有一部 Well, why do you have only one?
这都是一次性的 These are burners.
可以随意丢弃 无法跟踪定位 They are utterly discardable, virtually untraceable.
你在做什么 Uh, what are you doing?
我知道 I know
你杀了她 that you killed her.
我知道 I know
你怎么处理了她的尸体 what you did with her body.
信息已发送
加德纳先生已经接收到了信息 Mr. Gardner's gas has just been lit.
现在你只需要监视他 Now it's just a question of surveilling him,
观察他去哪里 做什么 observing where he goes, what he does.
做这些 你需要租辆车 You'll need to rent a car for that.
如果加德纳是凶手 If Gardner is a murderer,
我们的短信会让他惊慌 our message may throw him off his game.
他会因此露出马脚 He may reveal something to you which he otherwise would have not.
你去哪里 Where are you going?
去警局审讯嫌疑人 Police station to question a suspect.
你可不是唯一 You're not the only one
在案件上有进展的人 who's made progress on their investigation.
我认得她 Yeah, I recognize her.
她几个月前出现在新闻里 She was in the news a few months ago.
被人推向地铁什么的 She got pushed in front of a train or something.
是的 Yeah.
但你不是 But that's not
仅从新闻上知道她的 对吧 塞缪尔斯先生 how you know her, though, is it, Mr. Samuels?
我是说 I mean, you
在她死前 你们在同一个 you worked in the same office building together.
大楼里上班 Before she died,
她是个秘书 你是门卫 she was a secretary. You were a custodial engineer.
对呀 That's right.
我们在楼里见过几次 We used to see each other around the building sometimes.
对 对 Yeah. Yeah.
你还记得在地铁月台上看到她吗 Do you remember seeing her around the subway platform?
我昨晚得出一个结论 I arrived at a theory last night.
杀死塔利女士的人 The man who killed Ms. Tully,
曾经出现在月台上 he'd been on that platform before.
他到那里踩点 He'd studied it.
他知道摄像头在哪里 He knew where the security cameras were. Hm?
所以我开始看案发几天前和几周前的 So I began to look at footage from the days and weeks
监控录像 preceding her murder.
你猜我看到了谁不止一次地 You'll never guess who I saw following her
跟踪她 on more than one occasion.
这是案发前10天 Now, this was recorded
拍到的画面 ten days before her murder.
这是塔利女士 There's Ms. Tully.
那是你 There's you.
如果我没有看错 Now, if I'm not mistaken,
你手里拿着手机 that's a cell phone that you're carrying?
你很隐蔽 You're being discreet,
但你在拍她 but you are recording her.
你有犯罪史吗 塞缪尔斯先生 You have a record, Mr. Samuels?
2009年你因跟踪罪 You were arrested on a stalking charge
在佛罗里达被捕 in Florida in 2009.
那是个误会 That was a misunderstanding.
那这次也是个误会吗 Was this a misunderstanding, too?
你1米83 84公斤左右 What are you, six feet, about 185?
和嫌疑犯一样 So was this guy.
粘上假胡子 戴副太阳镜 Put a fake beard on you, some sunglasses,
几乎和疑犯画像一样 be hard to tell the difference.
-你怎么看 -我觉得你说的对 - What do you think? - I think you make an excellent point.
我不会伤害薇薇安 I would never have hurt Vivian.
你当然不会 不然你就不会跟踪她 Course you wouldn't. Nor would you have stalked her,
也不会用手机拍她 nor would you record images of her on your phone.
好吧 All right, fine.
你们说对了 案发时我在场 You're right, I was there that night.
而且我也乔装打扮了 And I was in disguise.
但我没杀她 But I didn't kill her.
我以为她发现了 I thought she'd seen me
我这几晚在跟踪她 following her a few nights before.
所以我就戴了帽子 围了围巾 So I started wearing a hat and a scarf
来挡住我的嘴 that covered my mouth.
我当时在那里 I'm there.
我只是没在画面里 I just, I'm not in frame.
这解释真省事 Well, that's convenient.
你不懂 我那晚也在拍她 You don't get it. I was recording her that night, too.
我可以证明 I can prove that
推她的不是我 I wasn't the one that pushed her.
我的天啊 不 Oh, my God, no!
你怎么看 So, what do you think?
是安森·塞缪尔斯的声音没错 It's Anson Samuels' voice, that much is certain.
问题是 视频是否被做过手脚 The question is, has the video been manipulated in some way?
如果没有 是不是塞缪尔斯策划了这一切 If it hasn't, did Samuels orchestrate the pushing?
他有没有雇佣一个精神有问题的人 Did he hire an equally mad associate
来谋杀他的跟踪对象 to murder the object of his obsession
而他自己就能在旁边拍摄了 so that he could record it for posterity?
我们现在还能拘留他 但最终 Well, we're holding on to him either way, but eventually,
如果不起诉他 就要放他走 we're gonna have to charge him or cut him loose.
我还希望 这条新线索 I was hoping that this new angle would shed some light
能帮我们找出凶手 但是 on the identity of the pusher, but...
不走运的是 as luck would have it,
这个手机也没拍到他的脸 his face isn't seen by this camera, either.
夹克上的臂章也看不到 Nor was the patch on his jacket.
臂章 Patch?
华生
失陪一下 Excuse me.
华生 还在监控吗 Watson. Still surveilling?
如果你所说的监控 是指坐着 If by "Surveilling," you mean sitting on my butt
看一个男人做些毫无异常的事情的话 watching a man do absolutely nothing out of the ordinary,
进行得好极了 it's going great.
我发的短信没起作用 The text I sent had no effect.
德鲁·加德纳一整天都待在画廊里 Drew Gardner has not left the gallery all day.
耐心点 华生 Well, patience, Watson.
侦探工作里最重要 There is no branch of detective work
且又最易被忽视的就是 which is as important nor as neglected
追踪嫌犯的艺术 as the art of tracing footsteps.
没事 我还能等几个小时 It's okay, I've still got a few good hours left.
其实 你没那么多空 Actually... you're not-- at least you're not good
至少晚上8点至10点左右你有事 between the hours of 8:00 and approximately 10:00 P.M.
什么意思 What are you talking about?
我无意间听到你昨晚跟一个朋友约定 I overheard you making plans with a friend last night.
如果我没记错的话 她叫艾姆 是艾米莉的简称 Em. Short for "Emily", if my memory serves.
天呐 我居然又忘记了 Oh, no, I can't believe I forgot again.
我记着呢 所以我提前联系了阿弗雷多 Well, I did not, so I reached out to Alfredo earlier on,
他可以来顶替你 and he is standing by to relieve you.
真的吗 Are you serious?
太感谢了 Thank you.
街头艺人 The busker.
什么 Excuse me?
那个街头艺人 拉小提琴的 The busker. The fiddler.
他在拉帕格尼尼[著名小提琴手]《24首随想曲》 He's playing Paganini's, uh, 24 Caprices,
作品一 第11首 Opus 1, Number 11.
往回倒一下 Rewind it.
停 There.
地铁站里我什么都听不到 I don't hear anything over the subway.
我也没听到 Yeah, neither do I.
那你怎么知道他在拉帕格尼尼的什么鬼东西 Then how can you tell he's playing Paganini's whatever?
能看出来 从他的运弓 指法 I can see it-- I know the piece from... the bowing,
和双音的弹奏 fingering, double-stop trills.
你不知道我拉小提琴吗 You don't know I play the violin?
今天以前我还以为你连饭都不吃呢 Before today I didn't even know you ate food.
我不懂了 这家伙拉什么曲子 I don't get it. What does it matter
有什么关系 what song the guy's playing?
是没关系 重要的是 他中途停下了 Oh, it doesn't. What matters is, he stops in the middle.
看 Watch.
他正拉着行板突然停下来 He stops halfway through the andante,
还没开始急板呢 doesn't even touch the presto.
问题是 为什么 Question is: why?
他为何匆忙停下 又离开月台了呢 Why does he stop so suddenly and leave the platform?
答案是 The answer is...
他看到了凶手 he sees our pusher.
他认识这人 He knows him.
他甚至可能知道那人准备干什么 He might even have known what he was about to do.
只要找到街头艺人 就能找到凶手 We find our busker... we find the pusher.
你们好啊 Hey.
我不知道你们俩也会来呢 I didn't know you guys were gonna be here, too.
是突然决定的 It was sort of a last second thing.
你们都过得怎么样 How is everything? What's going on?
我叫上霍普和肯是有原因的 There's a reason why I asked Hope and Ken to join us.
能给我一瓶啤酒吗 Uh, can I get a beer?
-之前你妈妈打电话给我 -是嘛 - Uh, your mother called me the other day. - Yeah?
-我们就聊起来了 -谢谢 - We got to talking. - Thanks.
我告诉她我们俩一直没机会见面 I told her how you and I kept missing each other.
她说你现在在做类似侦探的工作 She said you're working as some sort of detective now.
她非常为你骄傲 很兴奋 And she's so proud of you, excited.
但我听说这事时 我觉得... But when I heard, I just...
怎么 What?
我也说不清 我... I don't know. I...
不过这倒是从某种程度解释了很多事 Well, in a way, on the one hand, it explained a lot.
解释了这几个月你为何 You know, the way you've fallen out of touch
都不跟我们联系了 these last few months?
还有你跟我约了这么多次却都爽约 How you've made and broken so many plans with me.
跟霍普和肯是如此 With Hope and Ken.
还有其他人 With others.
我们当时就担心你 乔恩 现在也是 We were worried about you, Joan. I guess we still are.
你们是在给我开劝导会吗 Is this is an intervention?
不 当然不是 Wow. No, it's not.
只是一帮朋友在表示对你的 It's just a few friends expressing concern
担忧 for another.
这就是劝导会 相信我 That's an intervention. Trust me.
这种东西我组织过很多次 I have helped organize plenty of them.
在你还是做康戒陪护的时候 对吗 Back when you were still a sober companion, right?
在你辞去外科医生工作 After you were a surgeon,
但决心要做私家侦探以前 but before you decided to become a private eye?
抱歉我这么说 但你好像很迷茫 I'm sorry, but you seem lost.
从停止从事医务工作时你就这样 You have ever since you stopped practicing medicine.
我们知道你现在的新导师是你上一个康戒客户 We know that your new mentor is your last sober client.
所以呢 And...?
所以 "And...?"
乔恩 你辞去工作搬出公寓 Joan, you quit your job and moved out of your apartment
就为了全天候陪着一个康复中的瘾君子 so you could live full-time with a recovering drug addict
而他还准备教你怎么开展秘密工作 who's going to teach you how to be some sort of gumshoe?
你们俩有私情吗 Are you involved with him?
要是这样就容易理解了 Because that would explain a lot.
知道吗 You know what?
我以后再找你们吧 I am gonna see you guys later.
什么 乔恩 What? Joan!
我不觉得我有必要 I didn't think that I would have
-向你解释我的生活 艾米莉 -别这样 - to explain my life to you, Emily. - Come on.
要是我告诉你我不干记者了 I mean, what would you say to me if I told you
而要去做个什么风帆冲浪运动员 I was quitting journalism to become a...
你会做何反应 I don't know-- a windsurfer?
或者霍普跟你说 Or if Hope told you
她不当老师而要去参加海军 she was giving up teaching to join the Marines.
发自 阿弗雷多 小白脸离开了 稍后短信地址给你
你真的只是会恭喜我们吗 Would you really just congratulate us?
还是说你会把我们拉到一边 确保没出什么问题 Or would you pull us aside and make sure everything was okay?
那么你觉得我现在做的事像风帆冲浪吗 So, do you think what I do is like windsurfing?
我不知道它是怎样的 I don't know what it's like.
但我了解你 I just know you.
我知道你不是做侦探的料 And I know you're not a detective.
是个私人仓库 One of those self-storage places.
你让我盯着的人跟管理员说了什么 The guy you wanted me to watch talked to the manager,
然后进了那边那个仓库 walked in that unit right there.
是那个箱子 That trunk.
这是他妻子的姐姐的 It belonged to his sister-in-law.
她觉得他会用这箱子来弃尸 She thought he might have used it to get rid of his wife.
你是说那箱子里可能藏着个人 Are you trying to tell me there's a person in there?
夏洛克今早给他发了条匿名短信 Sherlock sent him an anonymous text this morning,
说他知道尸体藏在哪 said he knew where the body was.
而现在 他就把箱子转移出仓库 And now, he's getting that trunk out of storage.
-我们得报警 -不 还不行 - We need to call the cops. - No, no, not yet.
-还不行是什么意思 -我想自己来解决 - What do you mean "not yet"? - I want to do this myself.
-那根金属片还在这里吗 -对啊 - Do you still have that slim Jim? - Yeah.
我没听到他锁车 Look, I didn't hear a alarm trip on,
所以只要我能打开车门就行了 so all I have to do is get past that door lock.
-乔恩 -怎么 - Joan... - What?
你觉得我办不到吗 You don't think I can do this?
不 我知道你能办到 Oh, I know you can do this,
你是我教出来的 'cause after everything I taught,
你现在在睡梦中都能撬开车 乔恩 you could jack that car in your sleep-- Joan!
住手 Hey!
赶紧住手 女士 That's enough, ma'am.
请你离开那辆车 Step away from the car, please.
出什么事了吗 Hey, is there a problem?
-这辆车是您的吗 先生 -对 - Is this your vehicle, sir? - Yeah.
我是这儿的保安 我在监控器里 I'm the guard here. I saw this woman
看到这位女士撬开了你的车 breaking into your car in one of my monitors.
你就是来找我询问凯丽的事的人 You-- you're the one who came to ask me questions about Callie.
我正在调查这个人 I'm investigating this man.
我有理由相信他杀害了他妻子 I have reason to believe that he murdered his wife
并把尸体藏在这个箱子里 and hid her body in this trunk.
什么 太胡扯了 What?! That's a lie.
要知道我是否在说谎很容易 There's an easy way to see if I'm right.
让他把箱子打开 Just ask him to open it.
什么 我才不用开箱子给你看 Excuse me? I don't have to open a damn thing.
他叫德鲁·加德纳 His name is Drew Gardner.
你可以拿手机上网查 You can look it up on your phone.
能找到他妻子失踪的报道 There are articles on the disappearance of his wife.
她六个月前失踪 跟这箱子不见的时间一样 She went missing six months ago, same time as this trunk.
请你打开箱子好吗 Would you open up this trunk, please?
开什么玩笑 Are you kidding me?!
如果她说错了 你就没什么好隐瞒的不是吗 If she's wrong, you ain't got nothing to hide.
你要是不开箱给我看 You can either open up that trunk for me,
就给他们看吧 or open it up for them.
现在满意了 Happy now?
我觉得这场景似曾相识啊 I have the very strongest sensation of Deja Vu.
我帮你付了保释金 I paid your bail.
他们正在办手续 Paperwork's being processed.
很快你就能重回社会了 You'll be released back into society shortly.
谢谢 Thank you.
过来前我跟阿弗雷多聊过 I spoke with Alfredo before I came here.
他跟我说了今晚的事情 He told me what transpired tonight.
你冒险赌了一把 对吧 You took a chance. Yeah?
天眷勇者 Fortune often favors the bold.
但今晚没有 But not tonight. Mm.
你的判断是对的 You were right.
那个箱子就是 The trunk was the same one
丽贝卡·伯勒尔跟我们之前说过的那个 that Rebecca Burrell mentioned to us the other day.
如果德鲁·加德纳不是用它 If Drew Gardner wasn't using that
处置妻子的尸体 那他是拿来干嘛的呢 to get rid of his wife's body, what was he doing with it?
我没亲自问过他 Well, I didn't speak to the man himself,
但我跟逮捕你的警官交谈过 but I did speak to the officers who arrested you.
根据他给警官的口供 According to the statement that he gave them,
他在收到妻子的视频不久 he sold the trunk
就卖掉了箱子 shortly after he received the video from his wife.
因为恼怒 Partly out of spite,
也因为他的画廊出现了危机 partly because his gallery was struggling.
他知道这箱子价值大几千块 He knew it was worth several thousand dollars.
卖给了他的一个客户 Sold it to a client.
这事他本可以告诉丽贝卡的 He could have told Rebecca that months ago.
不过他害怕 Mm. Well, he was afraid.
他知道那么做是不对的 He knew what he'd done was wrong.
他没权卖那个箱子 The trunk was not his to sell.
很显然 你昨天的到访提醒了他 Apparently, your visit yesterday inspired him
该说出实情 to come clean.
丽贝卡认为他用箱子来处理凯丽尸体的想法 The idea that Rebecca thought he'd used the trunk to dispose of Callie
所带给他的麻烦要远比 was more troubling to him than the idea
他为所犯罪行受到的惩罚大得多 of being punished for his actual transgression.
所以他联系了之前箱子的买主 So he reached out to the guy he sold it to
又把箱子买了回来 and made an offer to buy it back.
他昨天晚上去的那个私人仓库 The storage space that he accessed tonight
不是他的 而是那个买家的 was the collector's, not his.
他只是想拿回箱子 He was merely picking up the trunk
然后还给丽贝卡 so he could return it to Rebecca.
很显然 这一系列的事情 Apparently, there is a paper trail
都有书面记录可以证明 which confirms this series of events.
我当时很确定她的尸体就在箱子里面 I was so sure she was in that trunk.
考虑到当时的情况 你的假设很合理 Given the many givens, your hypothesis was good.
但是我还是假设错了 But I was wrong.
你对那个箱子的假设错了 You were wrong about a trunk.
但是并不意味着 That does not mean that you were wrong
你认为那个人是凶手的假设也错了 about the man being a murderer.
我一直在想 I just keep thinking
如果是你去撬开那辆车 that if you were the one to break into that car,
她一定会在里面 she would have been there.
但因为是我撬的 But because it was me...
今天结束前我还有另一件事要处理 I have another errand to run before tonight is through.
明天早上 In the morning,
我建议我们合作调查这两个案子 I propose that we begin working both cases together.
你帮我找到在地铁站推人的凶手之后 After you've helped me find my subway pusher,
或许我也能帮你找到凯丽·伯勒尔 perhaps I can help you find Callie Burrell.
巴赫 撒迪厄斯 你怎么走商业化路线了 Bach? Why, Thaddeus, you've gone commercial.
你怎么知道我的名字 How do you know my name?
你因为在地铁月台 Your many citations
表演被传讯了很多次 for performing on subway platforms.
我想这就是你现在 I'm assuming those are the reasons
换到地面上表演的原因吧 you're now performing above ground.
好吧 你们是警察 Oh, you're the cops.
不不 他才是 No, no, he is.
我只是个有责任心的市民 I'm a concerned citizen.
薇薇安·塔利这个名字你熟悉吗 Name Vivian Tully mean anything to you?
不 No.
或许看到照片你就想起来了 Well, maybe her picture will.
-不认识 -一个疯子把她推下 - No. - You were there the night
地铁月台的那个晚上你也在那 a madman pushed her in front of a subway train.
你抵赖是没用的 There's no use in denying it.
我们在录像上看到你了 We've got you on video.
好吧 没错 我在那 Yeah, okay, I was there.
但我是后来看新闻才知道发生了什么 But I only heard about what happened on the news.
事发的时候我并不在场 I wasn't there when it actually went down.
你当然在场 因为你一看到那个人 Of course you were, 'cause the minute you saw the pusher,
就收拾东西 离开了 you picked up your stuff, and you left.
为什么 因为你认识他 Why? 'Cause you know him.
我想知道你是怎么认识他的 I'd like to know how.
抱歉 伙计 我不知道你在说些什么 Sorry, man, I don't know what you're talking about.
你很明白我在说什么 You do know what I'm talking about,
你若能早点告诉我你们之间的关系 and the sooner you tell me the connection,
我就不告诉 the less likely I'll be to tell
这位贝尔警探你还是个扒手 Detective Bell here that you're also a pickpocket.
我之前一直在街对面观察你 I was studying you from across the street.
你技术的确很好 You're actually very good.
拉小提琴让你的手指很灵活 是吧 Fiddling must keep those fingers nimble, hmm?
警探 能让我们单独谈谈吗 Detective, would you give us a moment, please?
听我说 我不认识那个人 Look, I didn't know the guy, okay?
我只是认识那张脸 I just knew his face.
案发前几天晚上我在地铁月台上见过他 I'd seen him on the platform a few nights before,
我想要偷他的钱包 被他抓住了 tried to lift his wallet, he caught me.
他抓住了我的手腕 我慌了 Grabbed my wrist, I panicked,
我使劲挣脱出来然后打了他一拳 hauled off and punched him.
他倒下 我就赶紧跑了 He fell, I took off.
案发那晚我看到他时 When I saw him the night he killed the girl,
我只是担心他会认出我来 I was just worried he might recognize me
并且报警 所以我就离开了 and call the transit cops, so I left.
你现在在观察我的外套 对吧 You're checking out my coat right now, aren't you?
在想从哪可以伸进手去 Thinking of where you can infiltrate it.
对不起 这是职业病 Sorry, okay? It's a force of habit.
当然了 Ah, of course.
外套对于扒手来说 I mean, a coat to a picker of pockets
就像保险箱窃贼见到了金库一样 对吧 is like a vault to a safecracker, isn't it?
你不自觉地就会去研究它 You've got to study it,
找到一个不会被发现的方法伸手进去 find a way in without being detected.
那么 那个推人犯 So... the pusher.
他夹克的这个地方有一个臂章 He had a patch on his jacket right here.
或许你能告诉我那是什么 Perhaps you'd be able to tell me what it was.
如果你觉得必须如此 不要这么做
If you feel like you have to, don't.
你找的那个街头艺人 So your busker was able
从一堆图片中认出了这个 现在怎么办 to pick out this patch from an image search. Now what?
向市民公布这张图 We bring it to the public's attention,
跟那副画像一起 see if it, in conjunction with the sketch,
看看有没有人能想起什么 shakes anything loose.
我觉得应该告诉你们 I thought you both should know:
我刚才把德鲁·加德纳请来了 I invited Drew Gardner to the station a little while ago.
如果你愿意道歉 If you apologize,
承诺赔偿对他的车 promise to pay for the damage
所造成的一切损失 you did to his car,
并且以后不再骚扰他 and refrain from any further harassment,
他会放弃对你的诉讼 he'll drop the charges against you.
我无论如何都不会接受加德纳先生的条件 I wouldn't accept Mr. Gardner's terms under any circumstances.
对 但她不是你 Yeah, well, she's not you.
华生女士的直觉一直在告诉她 Miss Watson's instincts have been telling her
那个人就是凶手 that the man is a murderer.
他说的对 我不像你 我不像你 He's right. I'm not like you. I'm not like you.
我 I...
我从没有过前科 I've never had a record before.
我和加德纳先生 Me and Mr. Gardner
会在我的办公室里 will be in my office.
说话前先想一想 Think about what you're saying.
我想了 I am.
我想了 昨晚就是一次警钟 I have. Last night was a wake-up call.
你只是犯了错 You made a mistake.
不 不光是 No, it wasn't just what happened
在仓库发生的事 at the storage facility.
我的朋友们也知道了我现在的工作 My friends found out what I've been doing.
我不知道你把这当成了一个秘密 I didn't realize you'd been keeping it a secret.
他们很不理解 They don't get it.
观点就像自动识别号码一样 华生 Opinions are like ANI, Watson.
每个人都有 Everyone has one.
或许你做的事 You know what, maybe what you do
别人是学不会的 is not something that you can teach.
或许这种本事只能是天生的 Maybe it's something that just has to come naturally.
我 我有很多事要考虑 I-I just... I have a lot to think about.
伯勒尔女士 我是乔恩·华生 Ms. Burrell? Joan Watson.
我们之前见过 We met the other day.
-请进 坐吧 -谢谢 - Please. Have a seat. - Thank you.
你是不是想再问问我关于凯丽的事 Did you want to ask me more questions about Callie?
实际上 我是来道歉的 Actually, I came to apologize.
昨晚在调查的时候 I got a little too aggressive
我有点太冲动了 with the investigation last night, and...
我恐怕福尔摩斯先生和我 I'm afraid that Mr. Holmes and I
不能够再继续查这个案子了 will not be able to remain on the case.
华生女士 Ms. Watson?
凯丽的夹克上 那块臂章 Callie's jacket-- that patch.
那是德鲁的夹克 You mean Drew's jacket.
那天很冷 It was cold that day.
他就让她穿着了 He let her wear it.
她管那件衣服叫"嬉皮外套" She called it his "Hippie coat".
好像是他在大学的音乐会上得到的 He got it at a concert in college or something.
这问题可能听上去有些奇怪 This is gonna sound strange,
德鲁以前留过胡子吗 but has Drew ever had a beard?
是的 留过一段时间 Yeah, for a while.
大约在凯丽失踪前后 He shaved it off around the same time
他把胡子剃了 that Callie disappeared.
怎么了 Why?
把我们手头的信息梳理一下 好吗 Let's start with what we know, shall we?
薇薇安·塔利在六个月前 Vivian Tully was murdered
被一个有胡子的人杀了 six months ago by a bearded individual.
我们知道了德鲁·加德纳大约在那个时候 We know that Drew Gardner wore a beard
留过胡子 at approximately that time.
他还有一件夹克 He also owned a jacket
和凶手穿过的那件一模一样 identical to the one worn by the killer.
几天之后 Several days later,
凯丽·伯勒尔录了一段视频 Callie Burrell records a video
视频里她说谋杀案对她造成了影响 in which she says the murder has affected her,
让她思考了一些事情 it's made her think.
于是她离开了德鲁 She leaves Drew.
多亏了你 现在我们有理由相信 Thanks to you, we now have reason to believe
德鲁·加德纳就是那个把薇薇安·塔利 that Drew Gardner was the man that pushed Vivian Tully
推下地铁月台的人 in front of the subway train.
问题是 为什么 Question is, why?
为什么这件事会对她妻子 What are the odds that it would
产生如此大的影响以至于要离开他 affect his wife so much that she leaves him?
有没有可能那正是他的目的 Is it possible that's what he was counting on?
如果是这样 他的计划是什么 If he was, what kind of plan is that?
他怎么能知道杀了薇薇安·塔利 I mean, how could he know that killing Vivian Tully
就会对凯丽造成这种影响 would affect Callie the way that it did?
我不知道 I don't know.
或许在这件事上我也错了 Maybe I'm wrong about this, too.
或许他只是碰巧有一件 Maybe it's just a coincidence
带有那个臂章的夹克 that he has that jacket with a patch.
我有没有告诉过你 Have I... have I told you
自我怀疑会分散你多大的注意力 how distracting I find self-doubt?
如果你非要沉湎 If you must wallow,
请你在自己房间独处时 再这么做 I ask that you do it in the privacy of your room.
需要我提醒你 我昨晚 Do I need to remind you that I made
因为判断失误而被逮捕了吗 a mistake last night that got me arrested?
需要我提醒你 Do I need to remind you
你今天的发现 that you made a discovery today
最终可能同时解决这两件案子吗 that may ultimately solve both cases?
你是想哀悼前者 还是庆祝后者 Do you wish to mourn the former or celebrate the latter?
因为我可是全力以赴的 'Cause I, for one, am fully engaged.
我想要破案 I want to solve this.
两起案件 Two events.
一个是地铁杀人犯 一个是失踪人士 One murder by subway train, one disappearance.
没有任何证据表明事件A Event "A" cannot reasonably be said
对事件B有任何影响 to have any effect on event "B".
但我们也无法排除 Yet it defies reason
两者相关的这种可能性 to think that the two are not connected.
我们知道薇薇安·塔利已经死了 We know Vivian Tully is dead.
我们强烈怀疑凯丽·伯勒尔也死了 We strongly suspect Callie Burrell is dead.
德鲁·加德纳和薇薇安·塔利 Drew Gardner, he has no discernible link
并无明显联系 所以 to Vivian Tully, and therefore,
对她也没有明显的杀人动机 no discernible motive for her murder.
但对他老婆 他有明确的杀人动机 He does, meanwhile, have motive for his wife's murder.
他们的婚姻陷入困境 The marriage was in trouble;
她又一次离开了他 she had left him once before.
现在的问题是 The question remains:
这起我们认为是 what are the odds that the murder
他犯下的地铁站谋杀案 we think he is responsible
促使他老婆 for on the subway platform
第二次离开他的几率 would compel his wife to leave
有多大呢 the marriage for a second time?
这个案件里 How, in this case,
A是怎么导致B的 does "A" lead to "B"?
也许不是A导致B Maybe "A" didn't lead to "B".
也许是B导致了A Maybe "B" led to "A"
我都不知道要告诉你们多少次 I don't know how many times I have to tell you people:
我没有杀凯丽 I didn't kill Callie.
事实上 Well, as a matter of fact,
在你被控告的谋杀案中 that's only one of the murders
这只是其中之一 that we're accusing you of.
还有另外一起 This is the other.
不明男士送花给女士 并将她推下月台
这是凯丽在视频里提到的那个女的 This is the woman Callie talked about in her video.
你觉得我跟这事有关 You think I had something to do with this?
六个月前 你留的胡子 Six months ago, you had a beard
跟那画像中一样 like the one in that sketch.
警察局 通缉中
你也有一件陆军外套 You also owned an army jacket
在右胳膊上有一个独特的臂章 with a distinctive patch on the right arm.
那外套我很久之前就捐给慈善组织了 I gave that jacket to Goodwill a long time ago.
你把你的胡子也捐了吗 Did you give them your beard as well?
还是你把它刮掉了 使自己看起来 Or did you shave it off, so you would look
长得不那么像谋杀薇薇安·塔利的人 less like the man who murdered Vivian Tully?
昨晚 当华生小姐 Last night, when Ms. Watson
说到你也可能是那个推手时 suggested you that you might also be the pusher,
我很困惑 I was confused.
而这并不常见 And that doesn't happen very often.
但自我辩护一下 But in my defense,
是因为按我理解 事件的发生顺序 the sequence of events, as I understood them,
根本说不通 just didn't make any sense.
你随机选择了一个女的 You choose a woman at random
把她推向死亡 and you shove her to her death.
几天之后 Several days later,
你老婆因这起事件离开了你 the crime inspires your wife to leave you.
第一起事件引起第二起的 Now, the odds that the first
可能性 几乎为零 leads to the second-- astronomical.
这时华生小姐想到 Then Ms. Watson recalled
你老婆以前也离开过一次 that your wife had left you once before.
那个视频 The video.
你说是凯丽六个月前 You claimed that Callie left it for you
留给你的 但你在说谎 six months ago, but that was a lie.
那是她一年半前录的 She made it for you a year and a half ago...
在她第一次离开你的时候 the first time she left you.
这太荒谬了 That's ridiculous.
假设我是对的 Pretend for a second that I'm right.
那视频确实是一年半之前的 The video is 18 months old.
在里面凯丽提到了一个女的 In it, Callie references a woman
被推下了列车月台 that was pushed in front of a train.
"拿着花的女人" "The woman with the flowers",
这是她的原话 to use her exact words.
这说明一年半之前 That would mean 18 months ago
还有一个女的被推下了月台 another woman was pushed in front of a train.
另一个拿着花的女人 Another woman holding flowers.
她的名字是安娜·彼得斯 Her name was Anna Peters.
当时她站在哈莱姆区的 She was standing on a platform
地铁月台上 有两个青少年准备去上学 in Harlem when two teenagers on their way to school
悲痛的哈莱姆区: 女士被推下月台
玩起了推搡比赛 got into a shoving match.
其中一个不小心将她撞下了月台 One of them bumped her over the edge by accident.
这事当时很轰动 It was a big story.
许多报道过该事件的媒体 A lot of the media outlets that covered it
都提到安娜当时准备去医院 mentioned that Anna was on her way to the hospital
看望病中的朋友 to visit a sick friend.
当她摔下月台时 拿着的花 When she fell, she was holding flowers
是她从自家花园里亲手摘的 that she had picked from her own garden.
她本来准备把这些花 Flowers that she was planning
送给她的朋友 to give to her friend.
很有趣 不是吗 That's interesting, isn't it?
那个六个月前杀害薇薇安·塔利的凶手 The man who murdered Vivian Tully six months ago
在推她之前也给了她一束花 inexplicably gave her a bouquet of flowers
非常令人费解 right before he pushed her.
你送给她那些花 You gave her those flowers.
为什么 Why?
你以为你有办法 You thought you had figured out a way
能杀死你妻子并顺利脱身 to kill your wife and get away with it.
你决定用她第一次离开时 You'd use the video that she sent you
发给你的视频 来解释她的失踪 the first time she left you to explain her disappearance.
而这时你需要的 All you needed now
是一起近期发生的地铁被推案 was a subway pushing in the present
这样视频才说得通 so that the video would make sense.
要推一个拿着花的女人 A pushing involving a woman holding flowers.
这太疯狂了 This is insane.
你不过是个编造 You're just some woman
疯狂故事的女人 with a crazy story.
你希望我有罪 You want me to be guilty,
所以你精心编造了这个故事 so you've constructed this elaborate fiction
以证明你的理论 to accommodate your theory.
所以你坚持之前的说辞吗 So, you're sticking to your story, then?
我将记录 你说 On the record, you're saying
你是六个月前 that you received that video
收到你老婆的视频的 from your wife six months ago?
我再次重申 就是这样 I am repeating that on the record.
我们也希望你这么说 Well, we rather hoped that you would.
今天早上我们被允许 We were granted access
登录凯丽的电子邮箱 to Callie's e-mails this morning.
很显然 你也能登录这个邮箱 Obviously, you also had access to those e-mails,
为了当别人问起这段视频时 because you needed to prove to anyone who might ask
你能证明是她发给你的 that the video came from her.
你从她的账号中删除了原始邮件 You deleted the original e-mail from her account--
就是她一年半前发给你的那封 the one she sent a year and a half ago.
然后你再在恰当的时机重新发送 You then re-sent it when the time was right.
问题是 The thing is...
我们在服务器里发现了相关存档 we found it archived and stored in the server.
我们知道 并且能证明 We know, and can prove,
你是在一年半之前收到的那封邮件 that you received that e-mail 18 months ago,
就在安娜·彼得斯遇害几天之后 a few days after Anna Peters was murdered.
但是 别太相信我的话 But... don't take my word for it.
我只是一个编造疯狂故事的女人 I'm just a woman with a crazy story.
艾米莉·汉金斯来电
你接电话了 You picked up.
太好了 我并不肯定你会不会接 I'm glad. I wasn't sure you would.
我自己也不肯定 I wasn't sure I would, either.
关于那天晚上 About the other night.
是你太过分了吗 You were out of line?
我不会因为担心你而道歉的 I'm not gonna apologize for worrying about you.
听着 Listen, em...
但是 我向你道歉 I am, however, going to apologize
我不该质疑你 for doubting you.
我的总编分配给我一个非常疯狂的故事 My editor just assigned me the craziest story.
"男人将女人推下月台 "Man Pushes Woman In Front of Train
以掩盖谋杀妻子的罪行" to Cover Up Murder of Wife."
听起来很耳熟吧 Sound familiar?
华生 Watson?
稍等一下 Oh, hold on a second.
等你说完了 When you're finished,
你可以下楼和我一起看些文件吗 if you could, uh, join me downstairs to peruse some files?
我以前在伦敦时的同事 An old colleague of mine in London
因一起谋杀调查咨询我的意见 asked for my thoughts on a homicide investigation.
我在几秒钟之内 I was able to identify the murderer
就找出了凶手 in a matter of seconds.
我想看看 I would like to see
你会花多久 how long it takes you.
今天你享受到一点点成功的喜悦 华生 You enjoyed a modicum of success today, Watson.
别被喜悦冲昏了头脑 好吗 Let's not let it go our heads, now, shall we?
艾米莉 Hey, uh, Emily,
我得去处理点工作上的事 something just came up work-related.
那下次再聊 Another time?
好 下次聊 Yeah, another time, okay?
再见 Bye.
乔恩·华生 职业：康戒陪护 居住在纽约市布鲁克林区 乔恩是单身
基本个人信息 我的职业：康戒陪护 我是：女性 我的地点：纽约市布鲁克林区 恋爱状态：单身
我的职业：顾问
我的职业：顾问侦探
乔恩·华生 职业：顾问侦探 居住在纽约市布鲁克林区 乔恩是单身